Thread Tools
Jan 25, 2009, 05:57 PM
Registered User
Discussion

If abortion were illegal: what should the punishment be?


Very interesting question, and one that I like to ask people who believe abortion is 'murder' or should be illegal.

Asking Anti-Abortion Demonstrators an Important Question (6 min 48 sec)


I would take this one step further: What should we do to women who smoke, drink, or engage in other risky behavior during pregnancy?
Jan 25, 2009, 06:11 PM
Registered User
The punishment would be for the provider of the abortion, not the recipient.
Jan 25, 2009, 06:23 PM
Suspended Account
Simple question, simple answer - If the crime is the taking of a human life, the penalty is the same as it would be for taking a human life.

But, of course, it is not illegal to have an abortion so it's a mute point. Roe v Wade will never be overturned.
Jan 25, 2009, 06:25 PM
Registered User
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jon Shaw
The punishment would be for the provider of the abortion, not the recipient.
Done illegally, by the mother of the fetus on herself, what should be the punishment? There is a reason why the term 'coat hanger' is used in this instance. What about drinking certain herbal teas to induce abortion?
Jan 25, 2009, 06:26 PM
Registered User
Quote:
Originally Posted by Johndou
Simple question, simple answer - If the crime is the taking of a human life, the penalty is the same as it would be for taking a human life.

But, of course, it is not illegal to have an abortion so it's a mute point. Roe v Wade will never be overturned.
That is why my question was "IF abortion were illegal..."
Jan 25, 2009, 06:47 PM
Registered User
Quote:
Roe v Wade will never be overturned.
Remember, it used to be legal to keep slaves and illegal to drink booze, so don't say "never".

I can't watch the video, because my sound is out, so, please bear with me. As to who would be guilty, I'd say the performer of the abortion would be the primary offender, although the woman and anyone who helped her would be accessories.

CD
Jan 25, 2009, 06:52 PM
Suspended Account
badaltitude's Avatar
There have been prosecutions for self-induced abortions. I have personal knowledge of one. The girlfriend of a friend's room mate.

And I noticed someone saying Roe v Wade would never be overturned. Foolish.

Never underestimate religious zealotry and pure vindictive idiocy.
Jan 25, 2009, 07:21 PM
Suspended Account
Quote:
Originally Posted by badaltitude
There have been prosecutions for self-induced abortions. I have personal knowledge of one. The girlfriend of a friend's room mate.

And I noticed someone saying Roe v Wade would never be overturned. Foolish.

Never underestimate religious zealotry and pure vindictive idiocy.
Roe v Wade was passed in '73. We've seen the most "right wing" appointments to the Supreme court that we're going to see for quite awhile. Plus, we just finished with the most religious zeolot president this nation has seen. Do you seriously think this country is going to go in that direction again anytime soon? Roe v Wade still stands after almost 36 years, a flurry of protests and a religious right that has thrown everything at it that they can. I think anyone still looking for it to be overturned in living in a dream world.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kurpal
That is why my question was "IF abortion were illegal..."
That's pretty much an impossible "IF" if you want my opinion.
Jan 25, 2009, 07:52 PM
Registered User
Quote:
Originally Posted by Johndou
Roe v Wade was passed in '73. We've seen the most "right wing" appointments to the Supreme court that we're going to see for quite awhile. Plus, we just finished with the most religious zeolot president this nation has seen. Do you seriously think this country is going to go in that direction again anytime soon? Roe v Wade still stands after almost 36 years, a flurry of protests and a religious right that has thrown everything at it that they can. I think anyone still looking for it to be overturned in living in a dream world.



That's pretty much an impossible "IF" if you want my opinion.
My argument does not take into account the relative probability of it coming to pass, simply the if it did, what would be the punishment. I understand that it is unlikely, yet these people still organize on street corners near my home. My argument is with those who say it should be illegal - what should be the consequence? To those who say it is murder, how should it be punished? How should alcohol use in a pregnant woman be punished? That also does harm to the fetus.

So if we can, get to the question instead of dodging it by talking about how unlikely it may or may not be for the question to become reality.
Jan 25, 2009, 08:15 PM
Suspended Account
Welcome back, BA. I hope you don't fall victim to overzealous and malevolent reporting-- again.
Jan 25, 2009, 08:46 PM
Suspended Account
badaltitude's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by redbird340
Welcome back, BA. I hope you don't fall victim to overzealous and malevolent reporting-- again.
Oh...I will.

It doesn't matter. Once a pedagogue, always a pedagogue. Reluctant learners are a constant challenge.

Here's the case with which I am personally familiar.


http://openweb.tvnews.vanderbilt.edu...-29-NBC-7.html


Abortion aside...take note that the military and intelligence services of the US have been torturing prisoners of late. Anyone who believes that right wingers won't reinstitute practices and taboos thought confined to the past just haven't been paying attention the last 29 years.

They'll be burning witches if enough wrongly assume they aren't capable of it.
Last edited by badaltitude; Jan 25, 2009 at 10:14 PM.
Jan 25, 2009, 08:52 PM
crashdummy6's Avatar
Some of you talk as if it is a religion against atheist thing.

I know plenty of God fearing people that are all for abortion. They all vote Democratic. There are also many pro-life atheist out there as well. I do not know how they vote.

Point being, everyone seems to want to attack pro lifers and their religion, what, exactly, do you attack the pro life atheist with?

As for the punishment if it were illegal. How about jail?
Pretty simple.
Jan 25, 2009, 09:09 PM
Suspended Account
Bilbobaker's Avatar
I think jail for punishment too and to the one who preforms the murder of the child.
Jan 25, 2009, 09:24 PM
Registered User
Quote:
Originally Posted by crashdummy6
Some of you talk as if it is a religion against atheist thing.

Point being, everyone seems to want to attack pro lifers and their religion, what, exactly, do you attack the pro life atheist with?

As for the punishment if it were illegal. How about jail?
Pretty simple.
First off, I did not bring up religion - you did. Religion should never be used as an argument for or against any potential position because it is inherently devoid of evidence. The reason why people argue against vast majority of "pro-life" religious component is that their justification for their position is based on religious grounds.

I have never witnessed a single atheist, let alone a group, on a street corner holding up a sign against abortion or a sign suggesting it is murder. I do not disagree that there are some legitimate reasons why some abortions should not be in practice, but in my opinion the reasons why abortion in general should be legal out weigh the reasons why it should not. I also have not seen an atheist opposing stem cell research on the grounds that a 3 day old embryo rights trump that of a 12 year old boy with a degenerative disease, and if I did I would hold that person as equally morally bankrupt as the less imaginary religious component of the anti-stem cell research community.
Quote:
I know plenty of God fearing people that are all for abortion. They all vote Democratic. There are also many pro-life atheist out there as well. I do not know how they vote.
I know plenty of religious people who accept scientific theory, support stem cell research, and are pro-choice. Stem cell research and evolution are both topics whose opposition is solely that of the religious aspect of our population. There are valid reasons to opposing stem cell research, and abortion, but I have never heard them voiced by the communities who currently oppose them.
Jan 25, 2009, 09:31 PM
Suspended Account
Bilbobaker's Avatar
Welcome back BA.


Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Category Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Discussion fvk bandit, which lipo and what should the throws be? franky31 High Performance 1 May 08, 2007 03:09 PM
What should my headspeed be? Trex with plastic blades... hogfarmer Mini Helis 19 May 17, 2005 01:37 AM
What Should the Headspeed Be on a 3D Pro? wannabe Micro Helis 3 Apr 20, 2005 01:06 AM
3D Contest: What should the rules be? davidleitch 3D Flying 0 Mar 31, 2005 07:10 PM
What should dihedral angle be? DLC Power Systems 2 Dec 07, 2001 08:36 AM