why do I get told not to use Li-Poly on mt trainer - RC Groups
Thread Tools
Apr 01, 2006, 12:46 AM
Registered User

why do I get told not to use Li-Poly on mt trainer

I have a fairly good background in electricity. And I am totaly puzzled that when ever I suggest using a 7.4V Li-poly battery in my Firebird Commander 2 with a brush motor, I get told it will damage the electronics. Would the different ri of a poly make any difference? As best I can tell that is what some are trying to tell me. To my knowledge any DC source, running a fixed voltage, should react the same as any other against the fixed resistance of any circuit. I would not think it would matter if it where coming from a NiMH, a Li-Poly, or a nuclear power plant. I talked to my Hobby Shop owner, he said Ii should not do it. He didnt know why but he had heard it was bad. I called tech support at my manufacturer and got a nice young fellow that said I should not do it because the li-poly had a higher maH so it would burn out the electronics, he said they had never tried it though. HUH? How does having a bigger gas tank burn up your planes circuitry. Well, I feel I have had to waste money on Nickle Metals 25.00 a pop, and a 40.00 charger when I should have been able to just go straight to the higher technology. Can someone give me the straight scoop here? Thanks so much for any help.

Sign up now
to remove ads between posts
Apr 01, 2006, 12:56 AM
It's been a while.
Daniel G's Avatar
It's the fact the your lipo will have a higher voltage than the regular flight battery and that the firebirds electronics will not shutdown the motor when the battery runs low.
If your firebird can handel a 6 cell nimh, then your lipo should work just fine, but when it runs out of juice, the electronics will not protect it so you will most likely end up destroying the battery.
Apr 01, 2006, 07:06 AM
turn, turn, turn.
The main reason is that lipos don't handle crashes as well as nimh. If you don't crash hard or often, who cares about the brushed motor in the Commander? Just don't wring it out too often, and when the power drops off, land. Simple as that.

I've used lipos in the Challenger when they first came out. Main thing is not to let the battery get too low. The motor will burn up eventually.
Apr 01, 2006, 08:09 AM
Sussex, UK
RobinBennett's Avatar
1) lipos can be damaged by discharging below 3v per cell, and planes that were designed for lipos have speed controllers that cut off at this point, the firebird does not. You can fit a 'liposaver' that will warn you when you reach this point, or calculate and time your flights.

2) lipos are easily damaged, people expect trainers to crash a lot and the firebird has the battery right up the front where it'll take the worst of any crash.

3) damaged lipos can explode, either imediately or the next time you charge them. People have lost their cars or houses.
Check out the 'lipo fires' videos here: http://www.utahflyers.org/
(In the 'video' box, at the bottom of the list, there are two)

Basically, there's no technical reason not use a lipo in that plane IF you understand the risks and are sensible enough to plan accordingly, but many people expect a beginner to crash too often and not to know enough about batteries and electronics to care about the risks.
Apr 01, 2006, 02:10 PM
Suspended Account
i went right to lipo's on my SS. the one thing i did learn was anything under a S400 does not like 3 cells.
did i ruin a few batteries...um, yes (one). did it cause any fires? um, no. was i safe when i noticed the big dent in the battery? you becha ya.
if your careful and don't abuse the lipo (i.e. dent, rip, mangle) and don't take it under LVC, then you should be fine.
Apr 02, 2006, 03:35 AM
Registered User
Thank you all Guys. I appreciate the insight.

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Category Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Why do shockie type fuses use balsa? Fly 3D Flying 10 Sep 20, 2004 09:24 PM
Do i have the record for the Quickest stripped diff on MT-2 MOOGLEYS Nitro and Glow Power Cars 5 Jul 20, 2004 02:14 PM
Question Li Poly on Corona Brushed Atomic Force? johnitahoe Electric Heli Talk 4 Jun 09, 2004 05:59 PM
Li-Poly on a Li-Ion cahrger? Ben_E Batteries and Chargers 3 Nov 29, 2003 09:06 AM
Not another Li-Poly question JDMstuff Batteries and Chargers 12 Jul 23, 2003 10:10 PM