Prolux 1-3 Cell LiPo Charger Review
Jon Walker reviews the inexpensive new lipoly charger -- the prolux 1-3 cell -- and finds it to have an amazing assortment of high-priced-charger-features at less than $30 US!
Introduction
|
|
| Prolux 3834 1-3 Cell Lipo Charger | |
| Manufacturer: | Prolux Hobby Co. Ltd. |
| Available from: | Zoom Resources |
| Price: | ~$45NZ+GST (~$30US) |
I recently received a couple of neat items from Bev & Trev at Zoom Resources to test and review. The first item I reviewed was the Advanced Avionics Apex V12 Switching Power Supply: an AC adaptor specifically designed for powering battery chargers from a wall socket. In this review, let's take a look at the Prolux 3834 1-3 Cell Lipo Charger.
As you are probably aware, there are primarily two charging choices for LiPo cells at the moment. At the sub $50 US end of the scale there are the cheaper chargers, which while very capable, usually require a power supply of over 12V to charge 3-cell and up packs. In the middle/high range there are some very capable chargers with built-in inverters, which will charge 3-cell packs from a 12V supply, but they generally start at around the $100 US mark. The Prolux 3834 Charger attempts to bridge that gap. Here is a charger that claims to charge from 1- to 3-cell LiPo packs from a 12V supply (i.e. it has a built-in inverter), but costs only $45 NZ (~$30 US)!!!
So does it do the job? let's find out...
ProLux 3834 1-3 Cell LiPo Charger
What's in the box?
Opening the box revealed the charger, a one-page instruction sheet (more on that later), cables and crocodile clips.
The charger itself is built in a small metal box of approximatley 5"x3"x1" (120x70x25mm).
The control panel features:
- the sockets for the charging leads,
- a five position slider switch to select the charging current (250mA, 500mA, 1A, 1.5A, 2A),
- a three-position slider switch to select cell count (1, 2, or 3 cell packs),
- a push button switch to start the charger, and
- an LED and buzzer to signal the various charging conditions.
The input leads enter from one side of the device and are terminated with standard banana plugs. The charger also comes with a pair of crocodile clip style terminators to convert the banana plugs into crocodile clips if you so desire. The charging leads plug into the top of the unit and are fitted with a standard JST style connector. Obviously you can cut this off and replace it with your preferred style of connector, or, as I did, simply make an adaptor to change the JST to 2-pin Micro Deanes for some of packs.
The Manual(or an exercise in translating instructions theoretically already translated into English.)
The single A4 instruction sheet was a good effort, but lost a lot in the translation, to the point where in some places it was downright wrong! A lot of the information was correct, once you figured out exactly what it was they were trying to get across, but some of it was so far off the mark it wasn't funny.
Fortunately, most of the errors will not hurt anything, you just don't get the beeps that you are led to expect. I spoke to Trev from Zoom about this, and he has indicated that Prolux would be more than happy to update the instruction sheet, if I could supply them with a better translation. For those of you who might purchase one of these devices, I have put a quick and dirty guide of what to expect when operating the charger at the bottom of this review.
Features and Specifications
| Features and Specifications | |
| Input Voltage: | 12V DC |
| Output Voltage: | 3 Position Selectable - 1, 2, or 3 Cell LiPo Pack. |
| Output Current: | 5 Position Selectable - 250mA, 500mA, 1A, 1.5A, 2A |
| Microprocessor controlled | |
| In-built invertor allows you to charge 3-cell packs with a 12V source! | |
| LED and Buzzer to confirm operation | |
| Automatic Cell Count Check | |
| Ouput short circuit and overload protection | |
For a low-cost charger the Prolux 3834 certainly packs in the features!
Aside from being able to charge 1-3 cell packs from a 12V source, and charge at five different charging rates, it also has both under-cell, and over-cell charging protection so that you don't charge your two-cell pack at three-cell rates or vice versa. One unique feature of this charger is a 'forced charge' mode for when your pack voltage has fallen below the detection voltage for that cell count. In this situation, you press and hold the start button for three seconds. The charger will respond with two beeps and will then charge the battery for two minutes only in an attempt to bring the pack voltage up to detection level.
Please note that incorrect usage of the forced charge feature can damage your batteries and, at worst, cause a fire!!
The Prolux 3834 also features short-circuit and overload protection on the output via a self-resetting PTC device. Not a bad line up for a 'cheap' charger!
Operational tests
As I really wanted to confirm that the inverter worked, I initially used an old PC power supply as a DC source for the Prolux. The one I chose put out a steady 12V, and is rated at 12A on the 12V line, more than adequate for testing. Initially, I set the charger up with a pair of meters attached so that I could measure the voltage and current as it was charging. I'm pleased to report that it worked correctly for all three cell counts, all five charge rates, and the inverter worked fine on the 3-cell packs! Later, I also used the new Advanced Avionics Apex V12 Switching Power Supply, with great results!
Having established that it wasn't going to fry my cells, I tested the auto-cell count detection which also worked flawlessly, giving different 'beep' signals to indicate too few (or too many) cells, and inhibiting the charge until the cell count switch was correctly set. I also briefly tested the short-circuit protection, and found that that worked fine too, cutting off the power at the first sign of a short. Being a PTC device, it does take a few minutes to re-set after a short, so don't panic if the charger doesn't immediately burst into life once you clear a short.
An unfair comparison test gives surprising results!
While I was doing my meter tests, I'd noticed that the Prolux has a low current cut-off of 250mAH (i.e. the charger cuts off once the charging current drops below the 250mA mark). This is not necessarily a bad thing, as it helps to avoid overcharging, at a slight cost in total battery capacity.
I was a little curious to find out exactly how much capacity this feature was costing, so I set up a test against my rather expensive (TEN TIMES the cost of the Prolux) European built charger. This charger charges right down to 30mA before cut-off, so it would give me a good indication of how much capacity was lost through the 250mA cut-off.
I fully charged a 2000mAH LiPo on the Prolux, and then put the charged battery onto my other charger at a 250mA charge rate. On my expensive charger I only managed to squeeze another 100mAH into the battery, and it took nearly ninety minutes to achieve that! This tends to indicate that the Prolux is charging the cells to around 95% capacity, even with a fairly conservative 250mA cut-off. Impressive!
Over the following two weeks I repeatedly tested the Prolux in 'real world' conditions. I charged a wide variety of packs of different capacities and cell counts. The unit performed perfectly throughout this extended test period, and no issues were forthcoming.
Conclusion
In its price range, the Prolux 3834 is by far the best dedicated lipo charger I have seen to date. It has many features that are normally only found on much more expensive models, and it performs exactly as advertised. The cell-count auto detect feature should save much heartache for those that use more than a one pack format, and the built-in inverter is a real boon for charging 3-cell packs from a 12V source. The ability to charge 1-3 cell packs, and the 2A maximum charge rate should satisfy the needs of the majority of indoor and park flier pilots. With a price of under $50 NZ ($30 US), this charger represents excellent value for money, and I recommend it to anyone looking for a LiPo charger in this price bracket. This charger has excellent 'bangs per buck' value!
A quick and dirty operating guide
N.B. Check your polarity whenever connecting batteries or chargers!
Basics of Operating the ProLux 3834
- Plug the output leads into the charger and connect the input leads to a 12V DC power source. The charger will beep once and the LED will flash once to confirm correct connection.
- Select the desired charge rate using the 5-position charge rate switch (250mA, 500mA, 1A 1.5A, 2A).
- Select the desired cell count using the 3-position cell count switch (1, 2, or 3 Cell pack).
- Connect the battery to the charger. The charger will beep once, and the LED will start to flash slowly to indicate correct battery connection.
- Press the Start button. If the switch settings are correct the charger will beep once and the LED will turn on solid to indicate charge in progress.
If the cell count switch is set higher than the actual cell count, the charger will beep rapidly and the LED will flash rapidly until you change the cell count switch to the correct setting. If the cell count switch is set lower than the actual cell count, the charger will bleep once, and then go back into standby mode with the LED flashing continuously.
Once the charge is completed the charger will give one long beep and then a continuous three-beep cycle with the LED flashing, indicating that the charge is finished. The start/select button also acts as a stop button. If you wish to terminate a charge prematurely, simply press the start button while charging. The charge will cease and the charger will go back into standby mode.
| Thread Tools |
|
|
|
|
Thread OP
|
Thanks Guys,
Re sourcing in the US, a funny thing happend the other day. I was browsing the EZone, and I saw what I think is the same charger in one of the rolling banner ads at the top of the EZone main page. The banner ad I saw featured two chargers, these were blue, but were dead ringers for the Prolux chargers in looks (the second changer in the pic was identical (except for colour) with the Prolux 2-cell lipo charger). I think they were branded "Elite" but couldn't swear to it. If I see the ad again, I'll follow the link and post it here for you... Alternatively you could try emailing Trev & Bev using the link in the article. I'm pretty sure that they are willing to ship o/seas. If you're going to do that though, it might pay to leave it for a couple of weeks as they are both away overseas at the moment. They are due back a week from next monday. And if you're worried about buying from someone in NZ please don't be. I know Trev and Bev personally (I see Trev every day!) and they are real good people. I'm even willing to put up a personal guarantee that you will not get ripped off! Cheers, Jon |
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
Thread OP
|
Quote:
I'm a big proponent of spending big on your primary charger (My primary is an Orbit 6 Microlader). You can't beat a high end charger for the versatility of cell types, charging modes, discharging, graphing etc. that you get with them. But yeah you're right, if you already have a fancy charger, the Prolux is great as a second charger for speeding up your lipo charging turnover  .And if you're only ever going to use low capacity lipo packs up to three cells, I reckon the Prolux is absolutley brilliant as your mainline charger. For that price you could buy a couple, and turn the lipos over even quicker .Jon |
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
I found this charger on a UK website as well, priced at 24.99 GBP (last item on the page):
http://www.addlestonemodels.com/aero.htm |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Thread OP
|
Found the link!
That would work out at about $75NZ I think LAN....
Also I found the link I was talking about before... http://horizon.hobbyshopnow.com/prod...?prod=EFLC3005 They call it the CELECTRA 1-3 CELL LIPO CHARGER It sure looks like the same thing though except for the colour.. Ths only thing is that the price is $44.95US. Could be a starting point for searching out cheaper retailers though. Jon |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Voltage Booster?
Jon:
Did you check the final voltage on a 3-cell pack? I doubt the charger has a voltage booster and you'd need a freshly charged lead acid battery to get 12.8V (typo, I meant 12.6V) final charge on a 3-cell LiPo. If the input voltage is lower than 12V I suspect that would be as high as it would go. That's the way others in this price range work. Rick. |
|
|
Last edited by rpage53; Sep 12, 2004 at 01:26 PM.
|
|
|
|
|
Thread OP
|
Hi Rick,
Yes I can assure you that the Prolux reviewed DOES have an invertor circuit, it is one of the main selling points of this charger. Final voltage of a three cell pack was 12.62V, even when I tested it with a 12 amp power supply that could only supply 10.5 Volts under load. Like I said in the reveiw - high end features for a low end price BTW, if you are getting 12.8V final voltage on a three cell charger then I'd throw the damn thing away before it does some damage! Li-pos have a MAXIMUM voltage per cell that should lie within (and NOT exceed) the range of 4.20 to 4.25 volts per cell. Three times 4.25V is 12.75V, so at 12.8V final that charger is overcharging your cells. It's only about .02v/cell over, but I'd still be cautious. Cheers, Jon |
|
|
Last edited by WildCardNZ; Sep 11, 2004 at 09:43 PM.
Reason: Missing info
|
|
|
||
|
Thread OP
|
Quote:
is it Trev and Bev (Zoom) you emailed? If so, don't expect a reply for another week or so, they are overseas at the moment. I'll drop a message here when they get back if you like. Cheers, Jon |
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
Yes, I did mean 12.6V.
I wondered if you used a battery because power supplies can be dirty and throw high voltage spikes that are just enough to provide the topping charge. One ad I saw for this charger said "TO 12.6V UTILISING VOLTAGE BOOSTER (NOT INCL.)". I'm sceptical by nature of anything that is priced too good to be true. |
|
|
|
| Thread Tools | |
| Similar Threads | |||||
| Category | Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Sold | Great Planes Electrify 1-3 cell LIPO charger - very inexpensive! | Etonic | Aircraft - Electric - Airplanes (FS/W) | 3 | Sep 25, 2005 01:47 AM |
| Sold | E-flite 1-3 cell Lipo charger | JREEVES | Aircraft - Electric - Airplanes (FS/W) | 2 | Jun 22, 2005 10:16 PM |
| FS: E-Flite 1-3 Cell Lipo Charger Brand New | mcoccia | Aircraft - Electric - Airplanes (FS/W) | 2 | Mar 02, 2005 08:12 PM | |
| WTB: BL ESC/1-3 cell Lipo charger | Bschulz | Aircraft - Electric - Airplanes (FS/W) | 1 | Nov 03, 2004 01:05 AM | |
| Inexpensive AC 1-3 cell Lipo charger | ScottChase | Batteries and Chargers | 15 | Sep 11, 2003 02:06 AM | |