Thread Tools
Old Jul 22, 2012, 03:14 PM
dll932 is offline
Find More Posts by dll932
Really?
dll932's Avatar
Discussion

Real interesting viewpoint on the American Civil War


http://fredericksburg.com/News/FLS/2...6242012/707305
Old Jul 22, 2012, 03:32 PM
Zaurak3 is offline
Find More Posts by Zaurak3
Gravity-Compliant User
Zaurak3's Avatar
The `house divided' part seems uncomfortably close to what we have now, with the big mix of politics/religion, and minimal compromise. I sincerely hope we can find some common ground soon, but I have my doubts - civil wars are never `civil'.

The last paragraph in the article deserves high respect:

"In commemorating the Civil War, we should remember that wars are easily made, difficult to end, and burdened with unintended consequences and unforeseen human casualties. We should also keep in mind that there is no higher law than the Constitution. That is America's Scripture."
Old Jul 22, 2012, 04:23 PM
dll932 is offline
Find More Posts by dll932
Really?
dll932's Avatar
You got it.
Old Jul 22, 2012, 05:08 PM
Libelle201B is online now
Find More Posts by Libelle201B
Registered User
Libelle201B's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zaurak3 View Post
The `house divided' part seems uncomfortably close to what we have now, with the big mix of politics/religion, and minimal compromise. I sincerely hope we can find some common ground soon, but I have my doubts - civil wars are never `civil'.

The last paragraph in the article deserves high respect:

"In commemorating the Civil War, we should remember that wars are easily made, difficult to end, and burdened with unintended consequences and unforeseen human casualties. We should also keep in mind that there is no higher law than the Constitution. That is America's Scripture."
That is a good post, but it should also be recognised that America has entered into many a conflict in it's history without declaring "war".
Old Jul 22, 2012, 09:22 PM
Zaurak3 is offline
Find More Posts by Zaurak3
Gravity-Compliant User
Zaurak3's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Libelle201B View Post
That is a good post, but it should also be recognised that America has entered into many a conflict in it's history without declaring "war".
I know it's not likely to happen, but, perhaps, with the experience of past entries into undeclared wars, America should reconsider this practice.

(But, where's the money to be made in doing that? )
Old Jul 22, 2012, 09:42 PM
LcJ is offline
LcJ
Find More Posts by LcJ
LcJ
Forever TMWT Pilot #11
LcJ's Avatar
Some important questions to understand why the way?

Which city in the United States had the most millionaires per square mile?

Which side needed the other the most to survive?

Which side actually brought the slaves into the United States to sell?

Which single area still seems to run the United States in almost every sense?

Introspection is good.
RCG Plus Member
Latest blog entry: RC Logger's Eye One Xtreme Quad
Old Jul 22, 2012, 10:53 PM
Indiana_Geoff is online now
Find More Posts by Indiana_Geoff
Random Pic #23982
Indiana_Geoff's Avatar
I thought it was a pretty weak article. It failed to use more than conjecture to support it's main points.
Old Jul 23, 2012, 07:43 AM
Kenny Sharp is offline
Find More Posts by Kenny Sharp
turn, turn, turn.
The people who started the civil war were idiots... they had no idea how to argue or compromise.
Today we are a much more enlightened society.
Old Jul 23, 2012, 09:41 AM
Treetop is offline
Find More Posts by Treetop
sensitive artsy type
Treetop's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Indiana_Geoff View Post
I thought it was a pretty weak article. It failed to use more than conjecture to support it's main points.
I didn't think so, it had a lot of truth in it, and for many, perhaps shed some light on why there was no compromise, and how the resulting "freeing of the slaves" really did little for blacks in the south until 100 years later. The war bred resentment in the south of the union, the freed slaves, and showed how even with the slaves free, little was done to enforce their rights, they were never accepted into society in the north or the south, as equals, until the civil rights movement a century later, and the resentment remained and it touched off violence, murder and further isolated the south. A south that remained poor and still remains poorer today. The civil rights movement and the steadfast creed of non-violence from the strongest leader of that movement, MLK, can never be overestimated as to how that served this nation. That could have gone much worse than it did, and it was bad enough.
Old Jul 23, 2012, 11:02 AM
Jim Thomerson is offline
Find More Posts by Jim Thomerson
Registered User
In a book I read, "Founding Brothers", the author makes the case that one a major accomplishments of the founders of our country was, by politicking and wheeling and dealing, they put off the inevitable civil war until the country was strong enough to survive it.

I think accepting slavery was the major mistake we made as a nation. The social consequences with be with us for generations to come.
Old Jul 23, 2012, 11:15 AM
LcJ is offline
LcJ
Find More Posts by LcJ
LcJ
Forever TMWT Pilot #11
LcJ's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kenny Sharp View Post
The people who started the civil war were idiots... they had no idea how to argue or compromise.
Today we are a much more enlightened society.
In whose eyes.....is the big question.
RCG Plus Member
Latest blog entry: RC Logger's Eye One Xtreme Quad
Old Jul 23, 2012, 11:44 AM
Indiana_Geoff is online now
Find More Posts by Indiana_Geoff
Random Pic #23982
Indiana_Geoff's Avatar
I would like to hear the compromise for slavery? What kind of compromise would be acceptable? Part time slavery? Maybe an early slavery retirement program?

In the end, slavery was incompatible with modern society. There was no compromise possible. You either have slaves or you don't. The North said no, the South said yes and was willing to rebel for the yes to stand.
Old Jul 23, 2012, 12:04 PM
LcJ is offline
LcJ
Find More Posts by LcJ
LcJ
Forever TMWT Pilot #11
LcJ's Avatar
Slavery would have ended under its own weight and the South could have survived without the North. How long could the North have survived without the South?

I have never been a proponent of slavery and do in fact consider it evil. But then at one time in this country you could used opium without a prescription. That was as recently as 1970. Paregoric's formal name was camphorated tincture of opium .
Robitussin A/C and Terpin Hydrate with Codeine both went by the wayside about the same time.

The sad part is that we still have slavery in this country and now it involves sex work instead of back work. How many missing children are now sex slaves to some pervert either here or abroad.

As bad as slavery was, not all were treated cruelly and many were prepared to work independently when slavery ended. Much discussion could take place here and in fact the life of a share cropper was many times not that much different than the life of a slave. When any person intentionally hold down the opportunity of another person by any means, including laws and taxation, their pursuit of happiness is limited and that isn't what we should have been all about.

Anyone other than me ever wonder what the world map would look like if Shaka Zulu had been in control of modern weapons and had access to shipping lanes? Interesting thought. Was he good or bad. He was both. Are any of us much different?
RCG Plus Member
Latest blog entry: RC Logger's Eye One Xtreme Quad
Old Jul 23, 2012, 12:19 PM
Kenny Sharp is offline
Find More Posts by Kenny Sharp
turn, turn, turn.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Indiana_Geoff View Post
I would like to hear the compromise for slavery? What kind of compromise would be acceptable? Part time slavery? Maybe an early slavery retirement program?

In the end, slavery was incompatible with modern society. There was no compromise possible. You either have slaves or you don't. The North said no, the South said yes and was willing to rebel for the yes to stand.
I am not convinced the war was even about slavery..
I think that is simply how history wrote it.
Old Jul 23, 2012, 12:22 PM
Kenny Sharp is offline
Find More Posts by Kenny Sharp
turn, turn, turn.
To answer your direct question though, there is no compromise for slavery... there are however, other things to compromise with or give up, to keep slavery at bay.


Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Category Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Sold $110.00, Gun Boat, Civil war, Model Shipways Picket Boat NIB Tim B. Boats (FS/W) 2 Sep 19, 2012 08:25 PM
Discussion Interesting viewpoint dll932 Life, The Universe, and Politics 22 May 20, 2012 04:55 AM
Discussion Civil War shipwreck CSS Georgia creates hurdle for government's $653M plan ken_nj Dock Talk 6 May 07, 2012 12:44 AM
Discussion Remarkable Civil War pictures dll932 Life, The Universe, and Politics 2 Mar 25, 2012 10:09 AM
Discussion American Civil War east6008 Chit Chat 0 Jan 15, 2008 02:51 PM