HobbyKing.com New Products Flash Sale
Reply
Thread Tools
Old Feb 03, 2009, 12:26 PM
Registered User
Fourdan's Avatar
Antony (France)
Joined Sep 2003
2,994 Posts
Mini-Review
Scorpion SII 3014-1040

Hi
I got recently, from Georges, some Scorpion new version 2 motors
I begin this serial of tests with the SII 3014-1040 (middle Kv between two brothers SII 3014 -1220 and -830).
Meaning of the appellation : stator size 30x14 mm, Kv 1040 rpm/V
Serial number (carved under the name) : JA0205

The general aspect shows some differences with version 1, particularly the rotor end-bell.
a) The five oblique venting holes are now five radial openings.
b) Motor delivered with new style golden 2.5 mm soldered connectors (MP-Jet style)
c) + female connectors set + 3 shrinkable tubes
d) one prop adapter collet type, 5mm motor towards 6mm/M6 for prop. Conical nut.
e) one alu cross mount and 4 metric screws for fixing the cross on the stator flange
f) Three colours (red, black, yellow) for the three cables
g) Appellation is now suffixed with the Kv. S/N is engraved.

Mechanical :
130 g (without cross, without prop adapter, with 2.5 mm male connectors)
Cross mount 4 g , collet adapter 8 g for both mounting modes (front or rear)
Wheel collar retainer (+set screw) on the shaft stator side 13 mm free.
Shaft end-bell side 9 mm free
Total shaft (diameter 4.97mm) length 68.3 mm
Motor fixing via 4 metric M3 screws on 25 mm circle
I dismounted the rotor. I am rather conservative and added some oil on the BB.

Stator 12 slots, diam. 30 mm, length 13.25 mm. I counted 70 laminations (thickness around 0.19mm)
Probably 9 windings turns per tooth; wires ?? number of strands ? I dont know.
Windings fixed by some points of glue (clear epoxy)
Rotor
Outer diam 37.5 mm, length 30 mm. no threaded holes on the end bell.
14 Magnets 14 x 5 x 2 mm
Shaft 4.97 mm L = 41 mm. Shaft over-passing 20 mm the end-bell
Airgap is estimated 0.36 mm.
Very small magnetic field leakage out of the ring.

Electrical :
Rm = 0,0276 ohm @ 20C (measured , not "computed by Drive-Calc")
So Rm is physical, without the ESC internal resistance

No load tests with an ESC 60A, timing auto
I made three connector-adapters F2.5mm (included) to M3.5mm in order to use my previous ESC 60A equipped with F3.5mm.
Io = 1.11 A @ 7 V , Peakeff in the range 86.9%
Io = 1.6 A @ 14 V , Peakeff in the range 88.7%
Kv = 1070 rpm/V , 2.9% a little higher than indicated on the rotor (1040 rpm/V)

Iron losses W = 0.5 + 0.455 * (rpm/1000) + 0.067 * (rpm/1000)^2 ; (best fit polynomial)

Test on my reference MAS 10x6 electric only (motor after some minutes warming):
8000 rpm V = 9 V, I =26.12A Power 235 W Thrust 1160 gf
9000 rpm V = 10.38 V, I =34.65A Power 360 W Thrust 1470 gf
This motor is very good for a power range 300-400W under 2S-3S

Improvement of that new version 2 versus old version 1:
I have compared efficiencies with version 1 similar Scorpion S3014-18. The gain in Peakeff is around 3.5%.
The efficiency gain is around 4% on the MAS10x6 E prop @ 8000 rpm.

The SII 3014-1040 is added to the new version of Scorpion Calc v 3.16

I am preparing the comparative results for several motors of that class 2814-3014 stator.

Louis
Fourdan is offline Find More Posts by Fourdan
Reply With Quote
Sign up now
to remove ads between posts
Reply


Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Category Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Discussion Kit Scorpion BL 3014. JoseLuis28 Electric Motor Design and Construction 43 Oct 19, 2009 06:34 AM
Sold Scorpion S-3014-16 rsasaki Aircraft - Electric - Power Systems (FS/W) 5 Dec 30, 2008 02:12 PM
Sold Scorpion S-3014-22 jadamian75 Aircraft - Electric - Power Systems (FS/W) 2 Nov 20, 2008 10:28 PM
Sold SCORPION S-3014-18 Outrunner punkindrublik Aircraft - Electric - Power Systems (FS/W) 4 Dec 16, 2007 03:33 PM