HobbyKing.com New Products Flash Sale
Reply
Thread Tools
Old Oct 08, 2006, 01:27 PM
Keep it simple
alfoot's Avatar
Salisbury,England
Joined Jan 2005
969 Posts
Discussion
Monotwirl Electric Autogyro

Hi,

An early video (23Mb) of the Monotwirl during one of the many development flights, this one in May of this year. I put a clip of it here previously, but this is a whole flight. I was trying out more rigid rotor blades (not such a good idea...), and it had a rather forward CG and too little aft rotor tilt angle. It has gone through many iterations since then, but I don't have any movies - yet.

Spot the designer BS at the end!!

Monotwirl Electric Autogyro - Early Rotor (4 min 28 sec)



Enjoy.

Al
alfoot is offline Find More Posts by alfoot
Last edited by alfoot; Feb 12, 2010 at 07:14 AM. Reason: Movie link changed
Reply With Quote
Sign up now
to remove ads between posts
Old Nov 04, 2006, 12:20 PM
Keep it simple
alfoot's Avatar
Salisbury,England
Joined Jan 2005
969 Posts
Well just for a change we have had some decent weather in the UK, so here is the latest movie (10Mb) of Monotwirl with the latest tweeks which are included in the forthcoming mag article.

Click here to watch Monotwirl-Autogyro-29-Oct-06


Enjoy

Al
alfoot is offline Find More Posts by alfoot
Last edited by alfoot; Nov 18, 2006 at 11:14 AM. Reason: smaller video file, better quality!!
Reply With Quote
Old Nov 05, 2006, 02:49 AM
Keep it simple
alfoot's Avatar
Salisbury,England
Joined Jan 2005
969 Posts
Here are a couple of stills from the latest movie. It is interesting to note the shape of the rotor disc, you can see that the blades flap up at the front and left of the disc (CCW rotor direction).

Al
alfoot is offline Find More Posts by alfoot
Reply With Quote
Old Nov 05, 2006, 03:43 AM
Registered User
JochenK's Avatar
Joined Jan 2005
1,286 Posts
Al,

very good. Nice, stable flight. Congratulations!

Jochen
JochenK is offline Find More Posts by JochenK
Reply With Quote
Old Nov 06, 2006, 01:03 PM
Robots... robots everywhere
minifly's Avatar
Cape Town, South Africa
Joined Jan 2003
2,060 Posts
C'mon, PLANS !
minifly is offline Find More Posts by minifly
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 30, 2006, 01:37 PM
Registered User
Ontario Canada
Joined Aug 2003
537 Posts
Al,

Congratulations on your Monotwirl.
In the second video, the machine appears to be much more stable & controlable.
What changes did you make to the rotor head to achieve this?

Thanks,
Bob
boberos is offline Find More Posts by boberos
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 30, 2006, 04:22 PM
Keep it simple
alfoot's Avatar
Salisbury,England
Joined Jan 2005
969 Posts
Hi Bob,

In the first movie, the rotor mast angle was at 5 degrees aft. The C of G was about 1 inch forward of the rotor axis and the 3mm thick depron rotor blades were covered in paper top and bottom, along with a double spar made from lollipop sticks - very stiff indeed. You can probably see that the rotor speed was quite low, round about the 200 rpm mark, and it needed almost all of the rotor tilt control to the right when coming in to land.

In the second movie, the rotor mast angle was changed to 10 degrees aft, the autogyro now balanced level when held by the rotor pivot and the rotor blades were now simple 3mm depron with a 3mm x 3mm spruce spar. Additionally, the blade pitch was slightly more negative, achieved by adding 1/16 balsa plates underneath the inboard trailing edge of the blades. The rotor has built-in flexibility/flapping and, as a result, needs little or no lateral correction throughout the speed range and is very easy to build.

In both cases the rotor rotates CCW as seen from above.

There were a number of iterations in between the two movies of course, but I have not made any further changes since the second movie.

Hope this answers your questions,

Al
alfoot is offline Find More Posts by alfoot
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 30, 2006, 06:17 PM
Registered User
JochenK's Avatar
Joined Jan 2005
1,286 Posts
Al,

this behaviour while landing is cuirious. You were using a CCW rotor and were pulling when landing. In my theory this would make the front ends of the blades move upwards, making it happen 90 later. This should have tilted the rotor plane to the right, and you should have tilted the rotor to the left in compensation.

You're sure about the right tlit?

Jochen
JochenK is offline Find More Posts by JochenK
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 31, 2006, 02:36 AM
Keep it simple
alfoot's Avatar
Salisbury,England
Joined Jan 2005
969 Posts
Jochen,

Yes, in the first movie I was having to use about half of the available lateral control to the right throughout the flight, and even more ( ie full right) when landing. Even then it still landed "left wing low" which contributed to the left undercarriage coming off.

On some parts of the first movie you can see that the rotor is level but the fuselage is leaning left ( ie right rotor tilt applied).

I'm not certain of the reasons, but I'm sure that the low rotor rpm had a lot to do with it - I had a number of "roll left at liftoff" incidents when I attempted to do take-offs at that stage of development. Once I changed the blade angles to a more negative value, the rotor rpm almost doubled and the left roll disappeared.

Al
alfoot is offline Find More Posts by alfoot
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 31, 2006, 06:23 AM
Winging it >
leadfeather's Avatar
Joined May 2006
9,400 Posts
Al,

Of all of the Twirl variants the MonoTwirl is my favorite. All of your creations look really good, but the extra measure of simplicity of the MonoTwirl makes it stand out nicely for me. It also lives up to the slogan in your avatar quite well!

I would love to know why the left roll problem occured. I wonder if at the lower rotor rpm, there was significant ASL; and being a semi rigid rotor, maybe there was large enough component of the resulting moment in the lateral direction to cause this roll???

Cheers,
Dan
leadfeather is online now Find More Posts by leadfeather
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 31, 2006, 06:56 AM
Keep it simple
alfoot's Avatar
Salisbury,England
Joined Jan 2005
969 Posts
Dan,

I think that you are probably right. The breakthrough was getting the rotor flexibility right. I must also say that I was lucky too, because I had, until one of Mickey's posts on coning and the resultant effects, completely misunderstood the concept when related to autogyros.

Fortunately the modifications that I did resulted in success but I might have got there quicker had I understood the theory a bit better. It was (and still is) a good learning process though .

I hope your New Year weather forecast is better than mine.

Al
alfoot is offline Find More Posts by alfoot
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 31, 2006, 07:09 AM
Registered User
JochenK's Avatar
Joined Jan 2005
1,286 Posts
Al,

I think the right trim you need while flying is simply a compensation of the motor torque. What really bothers me and what I have no explanation for is that you need more right trim when landing. Because when you're landing, you're cutting down the motor speed, which should mean less right trim. Your rotor speed will go down, too, and you'll have more coning. Which will cause a roll to the advancing blade, and with a ccw rotor, this means less right trim again. I'm thoroughly stuck.

Jochen
JochenK is offline Find More Posts by JochenK
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 31, 2006, 07:38 AM
Keep it simple
alfoot's Avatar
Salisbury,England
Joined Jan 2005
969 Posts
Jochen,

I agree with you. Unfortunately I was not rigourous in documenting the effect of each modification individually, and sometimes I made more than one modification at a time.

The differences between movie 1 and movie 2 were:-

C of G moved aft so that the autogyro balanced level when held by rotor spindle.

Rotor mast angle increased from 5 degrees aft to 10 degrees aft.

Rotor blades made more flexible and 3mm x 3mm leading edge spar added. This effectively gave a limited flapping hinge.

Pitch of rotor blades more negative.

With these modifications, I have not noticed any motor torque effects even though I have, on occasion, applied coarse amounts of throttle. The motor, by the way, has 5 degrees of downthrust but no sidethrust. There is now no requirement for lateral trim throughout the speed range.

I feel lucky that we are discussing why the Monotwirl flies well rather than why it flies badly

Al
alfoot is offline Find More Posts by alfoot
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 31, 2006, 12:35 PM
Registered User
Ontario Canada
Joined Aug 2003
537 Posts
Hi Al,

You explained your blade & rotor set up just fine, & I am glad it works for you.
But I am amazed that your blades flex just the right amout to simulate a hinged or flapping head. I am not sure I could trust myself to exactly duplicate your blade set up but will try.

Thanks,
Bob
boberos is offline Find More Posts by boberos
Reply With Quote
Old Jan 01, 2007, 10:48 AM
Keep it simple
alfoot's Avatar
Salisbury,England
Joined Jan 2005
969 Posts
Bob,

I wouldn't worry about the construction of the rotor - it is made in exactly the same way as the Twirl rotor. I used UHU Por glue throughout which is flexible, and allows easy removal/replacement of individual blades should the need arise.

Although it might appear to be weak, it has stood the test of time and the abuse that I have given it during the development.

I would avoid the use of "hard" glues such as epoxy as this would affect the flexibility, and make it more difficult to replace blades.

The picture shows how much the blades flex in flight - the rotor is built with the blades flat.

Al
alfoot is offline Find More Posts by alfoot
Last edited by alfoot; Jan 01, 2007 at 10:58 AM.
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Category Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Stevens G480 Video now up! skyyking Parkflyers 24 Apr 21, 2004 08:25 PM
The EdgeRC Pocket Combat Twin video is now up!!! birdofprey Parkflyers 6 Jul 31, 2003 08:31 PM
Interesting site with early bird video clips Ian Easton Scale Kit/Scratch Built 0 Jul 25, 2002 12:19 PM
Tomcat video now ready to view bipeflyer Electric Ducted Fan Jet Talk 43 Jul 24, 2002 07:04 PM