HobbyKing.com New Products Flash Sale
Reply
Thread Tools
Old May 19, 2002, 01:12 AM
Mechanical Engineer
ttnissan's Avatar
Florence, SC. USA
Joined Mar 2001
147 Posts
cAN I GET A LIST FROM THOSE WHO KNOW ABOUT SMALL edf'S

I'm looking for a lise of the smallest and most powerful EDF units aval. I have several projests going on in my head and i would like to have this info to base my purchases on. Like the KP44's, i know the AP20 will hop it up. that what Ken from K7A models told me anyway. How does it compare to the Vasa fan and others in the 2" or less size? maybe 2.5" i just need powerful and small fan units. Is there a brushless setup that will work in the KP44's? If you guys can help- i really need it. I love small planes esp. jets!

Thanks,
ttnissan is offline Find More Posts by ttnissan
Reply With Quote
Sign up now
to remove ads between posts
Old May 19, 2002, 01:16 AM
Http://www.aerc.biz
drbird's Avatar
Los Angeles
Joined Jan 2002
953 Posts
The Hacker B20 series motors will work with the KP44's - I am not sure which models are which but there are a series of the B20's that have a smaller front then the others - these will work - the KP 44's have small ridges inside that you will have to trim out but after that they will work like a charm - what kinda thrust are you looking to get from them - you might check out the GWS 75 when it comes out as well - WeMoTec also makes some pretty small fan units but the only place I know to get them is directly from WeMoTec - let me know more about the application and I will try to help you more
drbird is offline Find More Posts by drbird
Reply With Quote
Old May 19, 2002, 12:55 PM
Registered User
Ed Waldrep's Avatar
Las Vegas, NV
Joined Dec 1996
7,935 Posts
Besides the KP44 there's the WeMotec Microfan. 50 mm diameter (2 inches, the KP 44 is 44mm/1.75") and it takes a Speed 300. Thrust and current draw are higher than a KP44 (I can't recall off-hand what the numbers are). It seems to me to be a better fan, you can use just one to fly a jet since they will take 8 cells. With the KP44s you have to basically run two motors in series or run just one on 4 cells but where you can find a speed control that will provide BEC while running on just 4 cells is beyond me. The KP44 is best used in twins but even then there's not a lot of thrust, that's why I like the Microfan better, more thrust for a bit bigger model.

There was a problem with the microfan at first, it was a press on fit on the speed 300 and it you didn't get it just right it vibrated badly. The new rotors are attached with an aluminum adapter just like bigger fans so they run smooth. The Hacker B20 runs in this fan as does a new version of the Astro 010 brushless.

The Vasa 55 from Hobby Lobby runs on the Speed 300 and similar sized motors and has been reported putting out about 8 ounces of thrust on I think 8 cells. The unit is expensive but it's very light and runs smooth.

There's also the Vasa 65 from Hobby Lobby, it will take 400/480 class motors (there's two different models, one for 400 diameter motors and one for 480 class motors which are a bit wider in diameter). The 65/1 400 class motors runs well on my Kontronic Fun 400-28 and 12 x CP1300. I have this setup in my Wattage F-22 modified for EDF. Runs for about 4 minutes, I wish I had a bit hotter motor for more performance.

Hobby People has the new Powerfan 400/6. Diameter is 2.575 inches, speed 400 motor, a 480 might fit. The speed 400 that comes with the fan has a flux ring on it, diameter of motor plus flux ring is 1.135". 12.6 oz of thrust on 12 cells at 11 amps, that'd probably drop when installed deep inside a ducted airplane.

I mention the EDF 50 last because I don't have a very high opinion of it. It's a well built unit but the motor is small and it's meant for lightweigh slowflying jets. People are building heavy airplanes and putting these in them and they wont fly. There's not a lot of thrust, something like 3 oz. If slowflying in circles is your thing that this may be your ticket, but for myself I'm tired of poorly performing jets that can barely loop if at all. I like high powered aerobatics myself. I'd guess the KP44 has more power than this fan but I'm not sure. With the smaller diameter of the KP 44 it may have less thrust but I think it has more. The motor is a larger diameter in the KP44 but not by much (anyone feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, I have a KP44 but not an EDF 50).

There are other fans, mostly bigger, the WeMotec MF480 being the next step up (2 7/8" diameter) and very popular. Then theres the HW609 (3"), HW620, Midi fan (90mm/3.5"), HW730, HW750, etc
Ed Waldrep is offline Find More Posts by Ed Waldrep
Reply With Quote
Old May 20, 2002, 01:24 AM
Http://www.aerc.biz
drbird's Avatar
Los Angeles
Joined Jan 2002
953 Posts
I actually deal with both the KP44 and the GWS 50 - here are in my opinion the advantages and disadvantages of both:

KP 44
Advantages
Smaller in size
Much better construction
Uses Mabuchi FK series motor - Larger then the GWS
Capable of alot more thrust with the right motor
Disadvantages
More expensive then the GWS by at least $8 -$10
Heavier then the GWS 50


GWS 50
Advantages
Only around $15
All wires factory installed with quick connector
Added heatsink
Disadvantages
Flimsy shroud

There are more but this will get things going
drbird is offline Find More Posts by drbird
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Category Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Discussion Who can I get the motor from in the US swatpilot NeuMotors 3 Dec 06, 2006 12:05 PM
Discussion About Gun Control.. From Those Who ENFORCE It. Highflight Life, The Universe, and Politics 5 Jul 14, 2006 04:48 PM
What is the lightest motor I can get 400W from? Andy W Power Systems 16 Dec 07, 2004 02:10 PM
where can i get decals from on the net 1/7 scale R6JIMBOB Motorcycles 4 Aug 25, 2004 11:54 AM