SMALL - espritmodel.com SMALL - Telemetry SMALL - Radio
Reply
Thread Tools
Old Jun 12, 2012, 03:23 PM
Pirate Skipper
Joined Jun 2012
10 Posts
Discussion
AMYA Class Conflicts?

Waddup, fellow Skippers!

I've been sailing my Nirvana for a while now as a hobby, and have just gotten comfortable enough that I've started looking into Class racing. There are a couple of local groups here with various affiliations, so I'm trying to figure out which would be the best to join. During the course of searching, I ran across what is apparently a big ass conflict between AMYA and various international Class specifications at large. (There's a post about it here: http://www.sailrc.com/why-cant-we-pl...same-sand-box/ ) My question is, should I avoid RC clubs that are racing under AMYA due to their arbitrary treatment of class specifications? Thanks!
AhoyBlackHand is offline Find More Posts by AhoyBlackHand
Reply With Quote
Sign up now
to remove ads between posts
Old Jun 12, 2012, 03:34 PM
Registered User
United States, MA, Wenham
Joined Jan 2007
1,494 Posts
Where do you live?

In the USA?
You are governed by USA rules.
Logically You should follow AMYA as the governing body then.


Are you going to sail your Nirvana in Bangledesh?
Then does Bangledesh's Nirvana rules being in conflict with the AMYA rules have any bearing?


(Don't worry about it - sail your boat)
breakwater is offline Find More Posts by breakwater
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 03:36 PM
Pirate Skipper
Joined Jun 2012
10 Posts
Yeah, I'm in St. Pete, Florida, but we travel to the UK and Western Europe quite a bit. However, given the definitive tone of your response, I guess the best solution is one Nirvana for here, and one for there. Thanks!
AhoyBlackHand is offline Find More Posts by AhoyBlackHand
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 03:37 PM
Sport R/C Flyer/Sailer/Driver
United States, MS, Columbus
Joined Nov 2001
263 Posts
Personally, I would not boycott sailing in AMYA clubs. I do recognize that the class rules may be different between the two main Nirvana groups and will adjust my boat accordingly to sail in either group.

The class "conflict" is an AMYA issue that the AMYA and the manufacturer needs to resolve. I'm not going to hold my breath until it is fixed. Instead, I'm going sailing.
MMangus is offline Find More Posts by MMangus
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 03:43 PM
Pirate Skipper
Joined Jun 2012
10 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by MMangus View Post
Instead, I'm going sailing.
This seems to be the prevailing advice. Think I'm going to head out this evening.
AhoyBlackHand is offline Find More Posts by AhoyBlackHand
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 03:45 PM
Registered User
United States, MA, Wenham
Joined Jan 2007
1,494 Posts
Ah, I stand humbly corrected!

In the circumstance that you will actually sail your boat outside of
The USA, it does actually make a difference.
But, I can't give any guidance to the specifics of the Nirvana Class. I know zero about them.
I was speaking more to the fact that if you sail only in the USA, international rule is irrelevant. "House rules prevail."

Either way. Sail your boat, and bring others to the pond with you!
breakwater is offline Find More Posts by breakwater
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 03:56 PM
Pirate Skipper
Joined Jun 2012
10 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by breakwater View Post
Either way. Sail your boat, and bring others to the pond with you!
Always! I've got both my son and daughter hooked now.

P.S. That 360 seconds between posts thing is pretty crappy. I'm hoping that goes away after some posting threshold is met.
AhoyBlackHand is offline Find More Posts by AhoyBlackHand
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 04:05 PM
Registered User
United States, MA, Wenham
Joined Jan 2007
1,494 Posts
The world moves pretty fast.

Fortunately there is still an off switch- at the pond.

breakwater is offline Find More Posts by breakwater
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 04:36 PM
Registered User
flatlandsailor's Avatar
United States, KS, Wichita
Joined Feb 2008
359 Posts
That's an interesting blog post by Steve. I think the 'issue' that the Nirvana and RC Laser classes Might have with the AMYA (actually it's likely the other way around) is that the rules are manufacturer controlled. They do this primarily I believe to maintain the classes as very strict one design. However, I don't know if those classes (clearly folks more in the know about the way those rules are structured can shed some light here) allow members of the class to vote on proposed rules changes, or to suggest proposals on rules changes. If they don't, I would think that is what the AMYA has a beef with.

For example with the MM class, being an international class, has an international committee of individuals that are representatives of their offilliated national class associations. Those folks (me included as the USA rep) periodically vote on proposed rules changes that are presented by us as necessary. Now here in the USA class members that are AMYA members in good standing can vote on by-laws changes, elect class officers and suggest proposals for me to take to the int. committee for vote. It sounds a bit convoluted perhaps, but in order to maintain consistent rules across multiple countries and not splinter the 7000+ registered class members worldwide it's the best compromise yet devised. These contingencies satisfied the AMYA's requirements for us.

I don't know for certain why the AMYA would have issues with the Laser or Nirvana classes.
flatlandsailor is offline Find More Posts by flatlandsailor
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 05:29 PM
Sport R/C Flyer/Sailer/Driver
United States, MS, Columbus
Joined Nov 2001
263 Posts
From what I can see, the issue is who exact;y is the "Class Secretary". By the Nirvana class rules posted on SailRC and on the AMYA web site, the manufacturer decides who shall be the class secretary. Yet by the AMYA bylaws, the class secretary is elected.

I have no idea why the AMYA accepted the Nirvana class rules as they are written. But it puts the AMYA into an awkward spot. The manufacturer has appointed a new class secretary. That bypasses the AMYA bylaws on electing a class secretary.

So what we have now is two class secretaries: the AMYA class secretary, and the manufacturer's class secretary. Both are perfectly legal by the AYMA bylaws and the AMYA approved Nirvana class rules posted on the AMYA web site. Note that by the manufacturers viewpoint, the only official class secretary is the one the manufacturer has appointed.

Basically, the AMYA really needs to resolve the issue to prevent confusion between existing and future Nirvana owners when it comes to class rules, sail numbers, and so on.

Until then, I'll prepare my Nirvana to legally race in whatever class rules is in effect for a particular regatta. And in between races, I'll enjoy sailing the excellent Nirvana where and whenever I can.
MMangus is offline Find More Posts by MMangus
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 05:44 PM
Nirvana 38, Seawind 178
seabee CE's Avatar
United States, NC
Joined Feb 2012
501 Posts
I just sail by the rules of my local club. Unless you plan on sailing in an AMYA Nirvana event, has there ever been one, the local rules should be a good guide to follow.
seabee CE is offline Find More Posts by seabee CE
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 06:23 PM
Registered User
Joined Jan 2006
588 Posts
I thought the only issue was M class where the US had not deferred to the international rules and a US legal boat is not necessarily internationally legal. Mostly due to no depth restriction on the US rules. There is a depth limit for the international rules.
As there are only 4 ISAF recognized international classes M, IOM, A and 10R. Not sure why this is a big issue as other classes are pretty much set up by either an owner group or a regional/local governing body.
slotracer577 is offline Find More Posts by slotracer577
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 08:13 PM
**NOT GUILTY**
Capt.Crash's Avatar
Millbrook, Alabama
Joined Jun 2004
6,444 Posts
I'm so tired of all the politcal crap with this class that I'm ready to tear up my AMYA card and withdraw our club membership too.

The way I read the bylaws is that the residing AMYA secratary can nominate himself to be the secratary...no need for a vote ...and if he does decide to resign he can appoint his replacement...real democratic setup...

A few AMYA members (myself included) should not be able to speak for thousands of boat owners and change the one design rules. There will be no way you can set your boat up to take advantage of both set of rules. So you will have to decide which you want to follow. Me ...I'll stick with the manufacturer since it is a one design and AMYA will lose out in the end when it comes to my money and support.
Capt.Crash is offline Find More Posts by Capt.Crash
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 08:33 PM
FROM THE MIND OF A MADMAN
gpzy's Avatar
United States, CA, Los Angeles
Joined Apr 2007
3,276 Posts
Has there been a AMYA sanctioned regatta ? Or is it mostly just club racing ? Seems to be that the AMYA has had hands off the one design racing ODOM. Don't see why it would be any different with the Nirvana.
gpzy is offline Find More Posts by gpzy
Reply With Quote
Old Jun 12, 2012, 09:14 PM
Registered User
Monterey Bay California
Joined Feb 2004
14,090 Posts
I am a member of the AMYA and am totally unfamilliar with this as an "AMYA issue". I always understood the rules (not the RRS) for a particular class were defined by the class, not the AMYA. I have been aware of some differences in the US vs the Rest of the World wrt a specific class but I was always under the impression that that was up to those involved with the class to resolve, not the AMYA.

What do I know? (or don't know!)
Aerominded is offline Find More Posts by Aerominded
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Category Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Discussion Al Gore / Apple conflicts of interist UlteriorModem Life, The Universe, and Politics 0 Apr 10, 2012 10:58 AM
Sold Santa Barbara One Design R/C Sailboat, AMYA Sail number 1001 03ranger Boats (FS/W) 2 Feb 01, 2012 09:21 PM
Question AMYA Membership question? PingChandlerPong Sailboats 6 Jan 16, 2012 11:52 PM
Discussion Micro Magic is now an official AMYA Class! flatlandsailor Sailboats 1 Nov 28, 2008 11:47 PM
Proposed new AMYA class Panache II/Elite Climate Sailboats 0 Jan 14, 2003 02:08 PM