SMALL - Telemetry SMALL - Radio
Thread Tools
Old May 02, 2011, 07:55 AM
flexsphincter is offline
Find More Posts by flexsphincter
cq cq de kr4is
flexsphincter's Avatar
USA, VA, virginia beach
Joined Jan 2011
277 Posts
Discussion
why dont we build the spar first?

what im wondering is, as long as i build a straight spar, and do all to make it winchable/strong, then lay it on the plans, cut the ribs to fit to leading edge, and, cut to fit to trailing edge , throwing away the center/spar notch in rib it seems like it would be an easier /stronger build, what am i not seeing. does the "notch"in the rib for the spar mean any thing? ive got a 2mtr wing on the bench to be built and was thinking of going against the "conventional" build.
if i did the spar solo i cud put webbing continuous threw spar and shear webbing also instead of cutting to lenght between ribs.. ive searched the forums and not found the answer.
just asking
flexsphincter is offline Find More Posts by flexsphincter
Reply With Quote
Sign up now
to remove ads between posts
Old May 02, 2011, 08:05 AM
ferincr is online now
Find More Posts by ferincr
Registered User
Costa Rica, San Jose, San Pedro
Joined Dec 2004
1,549 Posts
I've seem few models built like that.
The first time I saw it I thought that the wing might break at one of those points alongside the spar (either in the front or the back of it) but the planking of the D box and the cap strips coming from the back to the top of the spar do a great job holding the whole thing together and the spars are rock solid having uninterrupted shear webs.
Just my $0.02
ferincr is online now Find More Posts by ferincr
Reply With Quote
Old May 02, 2011, 08:59 AM
ChuckA is offline
Find More Posts by ChuckA
Registered User
Tennessee
Joined Sep 2003
2,432 Posts
I have been building the spar first and adding ribs later for the last five years. http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=699593 shows how I build this way. I have crashed models built this way twice and the ribs break before the glue joint at the spar. I use epoxy to glue the rib to the spar and the sheeting extends behind the spar far enough to anchor the aft rib to the sheeting. The most difficult part of the build is to be sure that the nose and tail sections of the airfoil maintain alignment. The flat bottom airfoil used makes this easier but I have also cut a foam bed to the bottom airfoil contour for other airfoils. The last photo in the build thread shows the crash that destroyed the center wing panel. The model was rebuilt with a new center wing panel and flown again. http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=969978
ChuckA is offline Find More Posts by ChuckA
Reply With Quote
Old May 02, 2011, 10:20 AM
lincoln is offline
Find More Posts by lincoln
Registered User
United States, MA, Waltham
Joined Dec 2001
7,201 Posts
I did this on a model a long time ago. I cut 80 front ribs and 80 back ribs out of 1/32" wood (I think) so that the covering wouldn't sag much even without a d-box. Had tab on the bottom of front ribs to hold them up, which I got rid of afterwards. This was constant chord or it would have been even more of a PIA. Flew well but was ugly.

If you don't get the two rib halves perfectly aligned in the vertical plane, your glider will fly strangely.
lincoln is offline Find More Posts by lincoln
Reply With Quote
Old May 02, 2011, 06:42 PM
R2R is offline
R2R
Find More Posts by R2R
R2R
Registered User
R2R's Avatar
United States, FL, St Johns
Joined Nov 2009
669 Posts
The Airtronics Legend is built that way.
R2R is offline Find More Posts by R2R
Reply With Quote
Old May 02, 2011, 08:16 PM
John Walter is offline
Find More Posts by John Walter
Registered User
John Walter's Avatar
USA, IL, Naperville
Joined Feb 2003
858 Posts
The orginal Airtronics Grand Esprit was designed to build the spar first, then add leading and trailing ribs.
John Walter is offline Find More Posts by John Walter
Reply With Quote
Old May 02, 2011, 08:48 PM
MS_in_NY is offline
Find More Posts by MS_in_NY
Registered User
MS_in_NY's Avatar
Joined Oct 2009
553 Posts
Shear webbing is aligned with the grain going top-to-bottom of spar. This is done for deliberate structural reasons. There would be no advantage to a continuous piece of end-grain shear web even if you could find one, and handle it without breaking it.

.......Mike
MS_in_NY is offline Find More Posts by MS_in_NY
Reply With Quote
Old May 03, 2011, 01:41 PM
schrederman is online now
Find More Posts by schrederman
Hot Dawg Glider Pilot
schrederman's Avatar
United States, TX, Weatherford
Joined Nov 2002
7,999 Posts
If you look at Mark Drela's write up about the Bubble Dancer, it's explained in detail. The ribs, butted up to the spar, are only as strong as the butt jount and the materials adjacent to the joint. Having the ribs continue through the spar is stronger. I have built wings both ways, and I believe the continuous ribs make a stiffer wing in torsion, which is why I stopped building a continuous spar and using butt joints for the ribs.

Jack
schrederman is online now Find More Posts by schrederman
Reply With Quote
Old May 04, 2011, 10:19 PM
rogerflies is offline
Find More Posts by rogerflies
Registered User
rogerflies's Avatar
Thomasville, GA 31792
Joined Apr 2002
1,060 Posts
I built the spars first on my Saggitta XC. You just need to be really careful in positioning the front parts of the ribs to the spar.
rogerflies is offline Find More Posts by rogerflies
Reply With Quote
Old May 05, 2011, 02:48 PM
rdeis is offline
Find More Posts by rdeis
AMA 353531
rdeis's Avatar
United States, CO, Colorado Springs
Joined Aug 2003
6,641 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by schrederman View Post
...The ribs, butted up to the spar, are only as strong as the butt jount and the materials adjacent to the joint. Having the ribs continue through the spar is stronger. ...
I would think you'd want to cap the ribs with something that runs the full chord rather than relying on a butt joint.
rdeis is offline Find More Posts by rdeis
Reply With Quote
Old May 05, 2011, 05:46 PM
ChuckA is offline
Find More Posts by ChuckA
Registered User
Tennessee
Joined Sep 2003
2,432 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by rdeis View Post
I would think you'd want to cap the ribs with something that runs the full chord rather than relying on a butt joint.
I use epoxy for the butt joint at the spar and have never had a failure of the glue joint. The rib always breaks elswhere. The top sheeting extends 1 inch aft of the spar as suggested by Mark Drela and the bottom sheeting extends at least 1/4 inch aft of the spar. I have destroyed two wings built this way and the rib never failed at the spar.
ChuckA is offline Find More Posts by ChuckA
Reply With Quote
Old May 05, 2011, 07:55 PM
flexsphincter is offline
Find More Posts by flexsphincter
cq cq de kr4is
flexsphincter's Avatar
USA, VA, virginia beach
Joined Jan 2011
277 Posts
tu for the posts i will build next wing spar first ,,,because i can
flexsphincter is offline Find More Posts by flexsphincter
Reply With Quote
Old May 07, 2011, 09:33 PM
aeajr is online now
Find More Posts by aeajr
Proud member of LISF and ESL
LI, New York, USA
Joined Mar 2003
25,321 Posts
I watched a BD spar being built with alternating shearwebs and ribs and thought it was a very good and very strong design.

I am working on a Bird of Time now and it uses the same approach.

The shearweb's job is to keep the top and bottom spar at a constant distance from each other. I don't see this being compromised by having the ribs in the mix. This would be especially true when you wrap the spar with carbon, kevlar or unwaxed dental floss.

I also feel a rib that extends through the spar gives you better alignment.

Of course this from a guy who definately does not consider himself an accomplished builder.
aeajr is online now Find More Posts by aeajr
Reply With Quote
Old May 08, 2011, 04:37 AM
lincoln is offline
Find More Posts by lincoln
Registered User
United States, MA, Waltham
Joined Dec 2001
7,201 Posts
As long as you can wrap the fishbones, I guess you're right about no penalty. Haven't attempted that my self yet.

However, in addition to keeping the spars aligned at the correct difference, the shear web also carries the shear loads. Surprise surprise. ;-p

(thought experiment: Imagine that you've built the spar as normal, with lots of extra wrapping, except that between the caps and the shear, the glue never set. What happens when you push up on the tip?)
lincoln is offline Find More Posts by lincoln
Reply With Quote
Old May 09, 2011, 04:12 AM
aeajr is online now
Find More Posts by aeajr
Proud member of LISF and ESL
LI, New York, USA
Joined Mar 2003
25,321 Posts
I see your point on the shear webs.

As for wrapping, for a competition glider like the bubble dancer, wrapping would seem highly recommended. But for sport flying it is probably not required.

My Legend, recently sold, has carbon capped spars that were never wrapped. The plane is probably at least 15 years old and the carbon cap is fine, under the sheeting.

If I was building a plane where building the fish bone in order to wrap the spar was either inconvenient or impossible, I would still not hesitate to carbon cap the spar. Just make sure you get a good epoxy bond between the carbon and the spar.
aeajr is online now Find More Posts by aeajr
Reply With Quote


Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Category Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Discussion Why we dont have wheeled flaots.. VID pitviper51 Waterplanes 11 Apr 15, 2015 11:40 PM
Rant Why we fly (and build and fly) billyjim Scratchbuilt Indoor and Micro Models 50 Jun 03, 2011 04:36 PM
Discussion Why don't we get out of the middle east? Arbo Life, The Universe, and Politics 73 Mar 27, 2011 02:12 PM
Discussion The Aussie we dont drink instant coffee, II BMtech Australia 17 Mar 19, 2011 06:18 PM
Discussion Heli's, I mean big ones! Why dont we have em? dirtstar1 Fuel Heli Talk 41 Apr 24, 2007 03:38 AM