|Dec 08, 2010, 10:57 AM|
RC Motor Comparisons
This is my review of alternative motors.
At this point, I am using the GForce G10. See Below:
My first upgrade was to the Eflite Power 10, which is pricey but very reliable (and durable if you crash alot).
A cheaper alternative is the GForce G10 (http://www.valuehobby.com/product_de...=1&item_id=228)
Here are the comparative specs:
Eflite Power 10
Weight: 122 g (4.3 oz)
Max. efficiency: ??
No load current / 10 V: 1.2 A
Current capacity: 32A
Motor Diameter: 35mm (1.40 in)
Shaft diameter: 5mm (.20 in)
Overall Length: 43mm (1.60 in)
Suggested prop: 10x5 to 12x6 electric
Weight: 106g (3.7oz)
Max. efficiency: 80%
No load current / 10 V: 1.2 A
Current capacity: 35A
Motor Diameter: 35mm
Shaft diameter: 4 mm
Overall Length: 1.55
Suggested prop: 12X5, 11x8.5, 10x7
As you can see, the GForce G10 has a higher KV (more speed) and a higher current capacity (for larger props). The GForce mounts directly on the stock motor mount, but you need to use the prop adapter included. It's aluminum, and very prone to warping in moderate to hard landings. Be sure to order replacements prop adapters when ordering this motor. Also, you cannot use PZ props with this prop adapter, but you don't want to anyway.
Props: I prefer the APC 10 x 7 for it's speed, but it is not durable and breaks on hard landings. An alternative is the EMP Neodym 10 X 7, which like the APC, comes with inserts for different shaft sizes.
ESC: After trying several, I settled on the hobbywing pentium 40a esc (http://www.valuehobby.com/product_de...php?item_id=51). It is fully programmable, and incorporates a UBEC "Universal Battery Elimination Circuit", that converts battery power into a consistant and safe 5 or 6 volts (preset at 5) for receiver and servos. You will need to add Dean's connectors, which I recommend over the PZ connectors, if you choose to use the GForce Batteries.
As for batteries, I use GForce 30C 1800mAh 3S 11.1V LiPOs, (http://www.valuehobby.com/product_de...=8&item_id=336) which are less than half the cost of PZ batteries, and features the superior "Deans" connector.
The Motor, ESC, Props, and batteries are all available from Valuehobby.com, with whom I have had good experience.
|Dec 09, 2010, 01:02 PM|
Thank you very much for the information. It was kind of you to put it all together like that. I will take your recommendations and go with the G-Force motor and the ESC you described. I'm not sure of the programming card. Exactly how does that work and does it stay in the plane???
|Category||Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Discussion||FE Onboard Video Comparisons||questtek||Racing Boats - Electric||2||Nov 12, 2010 03:58 AM|
|Discussion||Impact of a Small Foam RC FPV airplane - Dangers and Comparisons.||JettPilot||FPV Aircraft||46||Aug 23, 2007 02:15 PM|
|Motor Comparisons Would Help||Gary Retterbush||Power Systems||5||Mar 30, 2002 06:27 PM|
|pager motor comparisons?||opualuan||Scratchbuilt Indoor and Micro Models||55||Dec 28, 2001 09:14 AM|
|Motor Comparisons||LNL||Electric Plane Talk||3||Jul 26, 2001 03:26 AM|