|Sep 07, 2010, 07:21 PM|
Joined Jun 2010
soldering station recommendations?
I just placed an order for lipos, charger, etc etc. I'm going to be doing some connector changing and typical RC stuff. I'd like to upgrade from the $9.99 Wal Mart irons of my past, to something a bit more versatile, and that will last longer. Mostly electrical work, but occasionally soldering together larger, non-RC connectors as well.
I have no "serious" background in electrical work; just the typical hobby stuff (RC, stereo connectors, misc electrical stuff, car and motorcycle work). I'd like to get some input from those of you who use, or know, about quality units. I'm looking for the best VALUE, not necessarily the best UNIT. The best unit will probably be more than I need, and cost more than I want to spend. I'd like to keep it below $90, ideally below $70.
Should I go with a 70 / 80 watt unit, vs a 40? Or get a 40 for electrical work, and a small "soldering torch" for the larger stuff (landing gear wire, battery terminals, etc)?
|Sep 08, 2010, 07:50 PM|
Joined Feb 2007
A 50 watts iron does not store enough heat to solder things like 1/8" dia landing gear wire or cabane wire on larger models.
I do not like using a torch for this purpose due to the risk of overheating the wire and potentially reduce its hardness.
So I have a 100 watts iron (American Beauty) and a soldering gun dual heat 100 w and 150 w.
I also have a 30 watts for printed board work.
I occasionally use a regular propane torch for big work. Those using a 14 oz propane tank.
Just to give anyone an idea.
|Sep 08, 2010, 08:38 PM|
A little torch is nice for the landing gear and stuff. A pencil
type iron is great for repairing small things and a gun
is nice for in between things..
All this said, soldiering is an art. It requires practice and
patients! It requires getting things clean and controlling
how hot you get the things you are working with. It requires
the right solder for the job, no there is not one solder for
all things. Resin for electrics, silver for load bearing things.
Low temp silver solder is fine, 1 or 2 %!
Before you solder anything important you need to practice
practice, practice...... Clean, clean, clean.....
Brad is a soldering guru and I have just recently learned
all about soldering and I am comfortable with most of it.
|Sep 09, 2010, 09:30 PM|
ZD99, second one down works great for occasional electronic use. http://www.mpja.com/productsdirect.a...item4=15141+TL
Can't help you with landing gear, I hand catch my DLGs. Maybe a Horrible Freight butane torch for that.
|Sep 13, 2010, 01:38 AM|
Dallas, Texas area
Joined Sep 2003
This solder station is an analog version of the one previously posted and it falls in your price bracket.
It is a very good product with excellent temperature accuracy.
You will need to buy about three additional tips for it so you will have the size for the job at hand.
It uses Weller ET series tips and I prefer the 'screwdriver' tips over the conical or single sided blade tips. They are under $5 each so its not to painful to buy a couple of them.
This solder station (or the digital one posted above) should last a lifetime and take care of most of your soldering needs.
|Sep 14, 2010, 12:17 AM|
Joined Aug 2010
|Sep 19, 2010, 02:19 AM|
I probably have one of these that I could let go for the right persuasion!
Let me know.
I use a standard cheapy 30W iron, for smaller electronics jobs, I head to the office or ask my lab tech... When that wasn't available I used either the Weller or Metcal.
|Sep 23, 2010, 07:07 AM|
Joined Dec 2006
I got razzed by the techy types, when I described my soldering equipment, which wasn't referred to as a "Soldering Station" 30 years and longer ago then this, when I bought it. I have a small pencil iron, a 30 watt gun and an old butane torch (that still has some butane in it). My Dad, who was excellent at torch welding, brazing and soldering always explained that solder flows to the heat. So, clean, clean, clean, use the right solder and apply heat where needed and in ample amounts and you will be successful! I also agree that soldering is an art form and practice has more to do with it, then state of the art equipment.
|Nov 03, 2010, 11:09 PM|
Joined Oct 2009
While there are better options, at that price point the Hakko 936 is probably the best bang for your buck, they're an excellent reliable unit and usually go forever if not abused. There are also many decent Chinese clones of these, which can be had at bargain prices (often these are found rebranded at big retail chains). Google for reviews there'll be many around and should steer you to a good one as there is a big quality difference amongst the clones, but the nice ones are very nearly as good as the genuine item. I did know the good brands back in the day lol but they've slipped my mind, look for ones that use genuine elements as well cause the chinese elements don't seem to last too long. The older styled Weller stations also are pretty bulletproof and well worth consideration (I've heard mixed reviews of the newer fancy German made ones, haven't used one myself).
With all the stations there'll be limits of too big for a given wattage and tip size. In my opinion it's best to find something that's ergonomically sound, reliable and that covers the vast majority of the work you're likely to do, then fill in any blanks by adding a regular iron or two.
If scouring the used market trying to get something real nice, brands I personally prefer are the OKi/Metcal Smartheat units, Goot and Hakko. Be sure to check out spares availability and tip prices of any model you may consider. There are some other exceptionally good irons aimed at the commercial/industrial segment but you'll often find the price of one tip exceeds the budget you've set, JBC and ESRA being a couple that spring to mind which are like that. Be especially wary of any Hakko product new and cheap from China or Hong Kong it's a heavily cloned brand especially the 936 and fx-951. If you can pick up an OKi PS-800E (the regular PS-800 comes with a crappy hand-piece) or PS-900 at a good price off ebay they're particularly excellent little kits which punch far harder than their wattage ratings would have you believe as the Smart Heat system is a lot more efficient than a ceramic element. I use the baby PS-800E at home, only 35watt but it'll tin automotive battery cables without much complaint, change the tip and I'm off on a circuit board working with smt components, no settings to adjust, it just works, temp is stable and well controlled, rosin flux bubbles away nicely and the joints consistently come out perfect mirror like. Both models go from on to full heat in about 12-15 seconds, which is nice, come with a beautiful little stand and there's a huge range of compatible reasonably priced tips. (between $14-22 for most, SxV regular and easy access production series tips will work on both irons), The 900 is the pick of the two, more wattage and a metal cased station vs decently strong plastic on the PS-800E, both are nice though and essentially make soldering a no brainer.
Some retailers that might be worth a look.
http://www.bomir.com/ (New Goot stations will be out of your budget, but the Goot regular irons are seriously nice to work with and well worth a look.)
Oh and keep in mind most commercial/industrial grade irons wont come with a tip.
|Category||Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Discussion||Soldering station recommendations..||CyberJay||Batteries and Chargers||46||Feb 28, 2010 05:49 PM|
|Wanted||WTB: Temperature-controlled soldering iron or 2-in-1 solder/rework station.||Cheesehead||Aircraft - General - Miscellaneous (FS/W)||1||Dec 25, 2009 06:06 PM|
|Sold||New Weller WTCPT soldering station $75.00 shipped||KCSO53||Aircraft - General - Miscellaneous (FS/W)||1||Nov 17, 2009 02:04 PM|
|Discussion||Which soldering station will be enough to solder batteries esc & motor connectors?||ath512||The Builders Workshop||15||Nov 04, 2009 04:17 PM|
|Sold||Weller Wtcpt Soldering Station||PaulVi||Aircraft - General - Miscellaneous (FS/W)||3||Sep 28, 2009 02:45 AM|