HobbyKing.com New Products Flash Sale
Reply
Thread Tools
Old Dec 01, 2014, 05:22 AM
Registered User
Nederland, NB, Waalwijk
Joined Sep 2006
260 Posts
Discussion
Custom ESC firmware with fixed max RPM for pylon racing

Hi Speedfreaks,

I am looking for a custom ESC firmware that could be used for pylon racing. We would like to get more equal racing by fixing RPM and prop size. That eliminates the benefit of buying the best batteries and buying fresh ones or each event. It will create a much more equal playing field for all contestants without costing too much money.
The reason i am looking for custom firmware instead of buying very expensive of the shelf ESC's that can be programmed on a PC is for 2 reasons: 1- Cost and 2-we would like something a little bit more tamper proof.

Do you know if something like this is already available? If not, I am looking for someone who could adapt existing custom firmware for multirotors for our specific needs as that seems the easiest way to go.

Many thanks for your help!!
MrBlobby is offline Find More Posts by MrBlobby
Reply With Quote
Sign up now
to remove ads between posts
Old Dec 01, 2014, 11:14 AM
Registered User
Canada, NS, Lunenburg
Joined Oct 1999
3,869 Posts
If someone wants to cheat, then fixing rpm isn't going to stop them. It is for example very easy to take a standard propeller and change its pitch.
DaveSawers is offline Find More Posts by DaveSawers
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 01, 2014, 03:13 PM
Registered User
Edhs's Avatar
the seventh planet
Joined Dec 2010
518 Posts
I raced in a class of racing that was simply limited by using a small esc as the limiter. For example we used a Castle Creations Thunderbird-18 esc. This limited peple to a maximum amount of watts the esc would take and pushing it beyond that was the risk of failure.
Edhs is offline Find More Posts by Edhs
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 01, 2014, 03:26 PM
2012 NZ Speedcup - 231 MPH
DownUnderPilot's Avatar
New Zealand, Tasman, Richmond
Joined Mar 2006
2,086 Posts
What airframes will you be using? Unless your lipos are huge it's probably easier to decide on a specific brand and KV of motor and then a prop that everyone has to use.... a good pilot with 30 or 40C lipos will beat an average pilot with 60 or 70C lipos....
DownUnderPilot is offline Find More Posts by DownUnderPilot
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 01, 2014, 04:45 PM
Tim Lampe; Hobbico R&D
KRProton's Avatar
Champaign, IL
Joined Dec 2009
3,900 Posts
Hi MrBlobby.

Iím not a speed freak, but Iíve taken to AMA EF1 racing recently. From what Iíve seen, most pilots arenít that critical about their batteries Ė Iíve seen some pretty rough-looking packs used by some of the fastest guys in the district Ė with pretty ďuglyĒ connectors too. Iím probably a little more particular than most about my batteries and connectors, and Iím just a mid-pack guy most of the time. From what I see, I just donít have the feeling guys are running out to buy the latest, greatest battery or buying new ones all the time. And prop size is already fixed (APC 8 x 8 thin electric).

I guess Iím correlating my experience in AMA EF1 to whatever kind of racing youíre talking about, but the way it is now, it doesnít seem to be a money race for the latest technology and in the end, simply the best pilots who fly the course tight, smooth and consistent with properly set up planes (and a good caller!) are usually the ones who win.

Anyway, if you fix RPM and prop size, there will probably be some other variable that can be tampered with instead.

I guess I havenít answered your question but rejected the premise. Sorry about that. In the end, it seems like the average Joe understands the spirit of the rules, abides them and just goes out and competes and has fun whether or not he wins. Then there will always be the couple of guys who are driven to push the rules to the limit (Iím not talking about cheating) and us ďaverage JoesĒ can either continue to enjoy the competition anyway, or quit.

Tim
KRProton is offline Find More Posts by KRProton
RCG Plus Member
Old Dec 01, 2014, 05:15 PM
Registered User
Nederland, NB, Waalwijk
Joined Sep 2006
260 Posts
I am an EF-1 racer myself, but this question is more for the Dutch group of E2K pilots that I will be joining next season. E2K is very cheap to race. Simple airframes but with very fierce competition. The last 2 seasons we are seeing large speed differences between the guys with the brand new LiPo's and well built planes and the average Joe's as you call them. We want to prevent this from becoming a LiPo war so limiting RPM and prop is a very simple way to do that.

There has been some testing already with YEP controllers, but setting the govener max RPM on those is not easy. The CC ESC's are easy but too expensive for the class. We would hate to make all participants buy one of those. To give an idea of how cheap E2K is I have a list of the major components:
Airframe, 2 kits available at around $ 60,-
Motors are cheap Turnigy 1400Kv outrunners of ~$ 15,-
3 Mini servo's
60-80 amp ESC $ 35,-
2200 4S LiPo $ 30,-
Speed of these things is around 200 Km/h so a lot faster than EF-1

They are hand launched at the start, 3 simultaneously. That makes for very exciting racing!
MrBlobby is offline Find More Posts by MrBlobby
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 01, 2014, 05:56 PM
Registered User
Joined Dec 2004
787 Posts
Did you happen to check in with the control-line guys? See are using some clever electronics (external to the controller) to keep rpm constant if I'm not mistaken. There is a thread on the Dutch forum on this, might be possible to use this for pylon too?

Gerben
Gerben is offline Find More Posts by Gerben
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 02, 2014, 11:58 AM
Registered User
Scotland
Joined May 2005
2,109 Posts
Which YEP did you try, what rpmp are you looking for?
Remember running at part throttle heats the motor and ESC more than full throttle.
Gerben, maybe you could supply them with a YEP already programmed to do the job? Then they would not have to program it and couldn't change the max rpm?
George Shering is offline Find More Posts by George Shering
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 02, 2014, 12:33 PM
Registered User
Joined Dec 2004
787 Posts
If it's possible to prgram a fixed rpm I'd be happy to George.
Am I correct in thinking the governer RPM is driven by a signal from the throttle channel?

I think MrB is thinking a pre-programmed ESC which drives 'any' motor at for instance 10.000rpm. Would it be possible to fashion some sort of hex which does that?

Gerben
Gerben is offline Find More Posts by Gerben
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 02, 2014, 01:29 PM
Registered User
Nederland, NB, Waalwijk
Joined Sep 2006
260 Posts
George, we are testing the YEP 80Amp and are aiming for 15.000 to 16.000rpm.

Gerben, nice of you to chime in. I checked the line control solution, but that needs a lot of change to work for us. It has no receiver input and acts as PPM source for a normal ESC.

I would like to keep the setup as simple as possible every link you add to the chain adds points of failure.

I have the hardware to flash atmel chips so all we need is a HEX where we can set a fixed RPM. From the top of my head the motors we use are 14 pole outrunners. Without govener we run 8x6 props, with govener we would like to switch to 8x8 to be able to get to the same speed and have a little headroom for the govener to work with.

Groeten Emanuel
MrBlobby is offline Find More Posts by MrBlobby
Last edited by MrBlobby; Dec 02, 2014 at 01:38 PM.
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 02, 2014, 04:53 PM
Registered User
Scotland
Joined May 2005
2,109 Posts
Gerben, you flew my YEP (same as the YGE) software in Austria. It works on the YEP 45, the YEP 150 from you, and the YGE200FAI. So I presume it will work on the YEP 80. I could remove the soft start software used on the YGE though it does nothing on the YEP.

I think I can add the rpm limiting easily as it similar to the ramping, but I would have to try. It would be for 14 pole motors only, though the code could be changed for other pole configurations by changing build parameters.

I am running out of time this year, very few programming days left before Christmas due to other engagements, but I will do what I can.
George Shering is offline Find More Posts by George Shering
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 03, 2014, 01:28 AM
Registered User
Nederland, NB, Waalwijk
Joined Sep 2006
260 Posts
George, that would be great! I really appreciate this!

What kind of tools would we need to make changes to your software? Once the program is working there is probably some tuning of parameters to do. If we can do that ourselves that would save you a lot of time.

Thanks again for your help.
MrBlobby is offline Find More Posts by MrBlobby
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 03, 2014, 02:34 PM
Registered User
Eindhoven
Joined Jul 2007
157 Posts
NTM has 10 magnets

As shown in the dutch forum, the most used NTM motor has 10 magnets.
The aerodrive has 14.

A modified controller would be perfect.

CC I tested in governer mode has a very slow spool up time of 2 seconds, and no reduced power possibility for landing.
Works, but far from perfect.

Tjarko
tjarko is offline Find More Posts by tjarko
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 03, 2014, 02:41 PM
Registered User
Scotland
Joined May 2005
2,109 Posts
Here is a first attempt. I can't do any more until next week, so this will give you a chance to check the YEP 80 and the downloading system.
Remember, first tests using a current limited supply in case of short circuits.
Then keep checking the temperature of the FETs.
In my test this code has trouble starting and stopping, interaction between the throttle ramp and rpm limiter I think. But when it is running it seems to limit the rpm to just under 15000.

Very short of time between now and Christmas so if you can try as much as possible and give me feedback right away.

I use Atmel Studio 6.1 and an AVRISP for development. Code written in C with assembler macros.

ps Tjarko: this code is for 14 pole motor, don't use 10 pole. Different code required.
George Shering is offline Find More Posts by George Shering
Reply With Quote
Old Dec 03, 2014, 04:28 PM
Registered User
Nederland, NB, Waalwijk
Joined Sep 2006
260 Posts
Wow that was quick. I am impressed. This will make the esc function as normal but with limited RPM?
I will check out the software asap.
MrBlobby is offline Find More Posts by MrBlobby
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Category Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Discussion Max/Min Voltage for the Glow Driver/Pylon Racing Dave Yost Pylon Racing 17 Nov 07, 2014 01:39 PM
Discussion Max/Min Voltage for Glow Driver/Pylon Racing Dave Yost Pylon Racing 1 Sep 21, 2014 06:56 PM
Sold Jett 40 aac super sport for ama 426 pylon racing with mount & prop Whitman Flyers Aircraft - Fuel - Engines and Accessories (FS/W) 3 Aug 03, 2014 10:56 AM
Discussion What firmware version for the smoothest motor startup with Mamba Max esc? Steve Klyce Castle Creations 0 Nov 05, 2010 10:56 PM
Help! Need Help Fast - Rpm For An "a" Gws Motor -ips Pylon Race SPEED-E-FLYER Electric Plane Talk 15 Mar 15, 2006 10:20 PM