HobbyKing.com New Products Flash Sale
Reply
Thread Tools
Old Feb 08, 2013, 06:13 PM
Registered User
So. Cal
Joined Jan 2005
137 Posts
Discussion
The lazy method - Carbon Spar Caps

I am wanting to cap my spars in the center section with carbon and have found the numerous postings that discuss the process. The plane has a relatively small spar cap (3/8x1/8) and I noticed that I can just a replacement piece of carbon with the same size as the bass spar caps, therefore avoiding the gluing and fitting process.

Two main questions -

1. Why not just replace the bass spar cap witth the carbon one vs. laminating the carbon tape? Too much added weight? Cost?
2. Does a nostalgia class plane get disqualified using a solid carbon spar cap?

I am about to order the carbon and just wanted some feedback on this idea before I push the order button.

Thank you for any input.

Craig
TOSSPilot is offline Find More Posts by TOSSPilot
Reply With Quote
Sign up now
to remove ads between posts
Old Feb 08, 2013, 08:08 PM
Unrepentant Paragon addict
LVsoaring's Avatar
United States, OK, Moore
Joined Jan 2006
2,528 Posts
1) I would think cost would certainly be a factor...

2) Good question..... I don't know but am interested to find out.
LVsoaring is offline Find More Posts by LVsoaring
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 08, 2013, 10:39 PM
Registered User
1967250s's Avatar
United States, VA, Alexandria
Joined Sep 2008
987 Posts
Does it really need a stronger spar cap? What plane is it? Wing dimensions? Skin/covering?
What will be it's uses?
1967250s is offline Find More Posts by 1967250s
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 08, 2013, 11:17 PM
Registered User
So. Cal
Joined Jan 2005
137 Posts
It is the Mirage. The wing strength is probably decent in stock form and I know this would be an over kill but I do plan on flying it in open class competition and would like the extra launch/winch ability without worry.

I do plan on wrapping the joiner boxes with kevlar thread. Not sure if I am creating a major stress point at the wing joiner box going from carbon spar back to bass wood in the tip panels?

The cost is about $25 vs. $8 for the tape but not really a big concern if it is easier than laminating carbon tape and sanding down the wood for the correct fit.

I have not seen too many post about just replacing the entire spar cap with a pure carbon cap.

Thank you again for the thoughts

.

Craig
TOSSPilot is offline Find More Posts by TOSSPilot
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 08, 2013, 11:22 PM
Registered User
So. Cal
Joined Jan 2005
137 Posts
On the CST website, this is the product.

Carbon Fiber Rectangle, 0.125" x 0.375" x 48"
3.2 mm x 9.5 mm x 1.2 m, ??? grams T726L4 $12.95
TOSSPilot is offline Find More Posts by TOSSPilot
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 09, 2013, 02:36 AM
Registered User
ieyasu's Avatar
USA, CO, Fort Collins
Joined Sep 2010
181 Posts
In case it's not too late, here are some numbers. Carbon fiber is something like 20-30x stronger than spruce or basswood for an equal size, but it's also heavier. If you use solid 1/8x3/8 carbon caps, I'd bet everything else in the wing will break before those caps. Some quick math shows each 48" cap would weigh about 2 ounces, while a wood cap of the same size would be more like 0.6~0.7 ounce.

If this page is still authoritative, you just might squeak by with a solid carbon spar, depending on the CD.
ieyasu is offline Find More Posts by ieyasu
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 09, 2013, 03:04 AM
Balsa breaks better
Thermaler's Avatar
Buchanan Mi
Joined Apr 2005
2,066 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by ieyasu View Post
If this page is still authoritative, you just might squeak by with a solid carbon spar, depending on the CD.
Those are the original rules not the current rules.

Joe

thermalrider.com
Thermaler is offline Find More Posts by Thermaler
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 09, 2013, 09:44 AM
Registered User
John Walter's Avatar
USA, IL, Naperville
Joined Feb 2003
856 Posts
The Miarage is a great plane. The key to its design is the balance among all is components.

A solid CF spar will weigh too much. Without changing the rest of the spar, you would simlpy tear off the tips before the main spar saw any substantial load. Also, since there is no balsa sheeting, the wing would flutter long before the main spar loads became an issue.

.007 CF on the top spar, or .014 top and .007 bottom would give more than plenty of strength.
John Walter is offline Find More Posts by John Walter
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 09, 2013, 10:01 AM
Unrepentant Paragon addict
LVsoaring's Avatar
United States, OK, Moore
Joined Jan 2006
2,528 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by TOSSPilot View Post
It is the Mirage. The wing strength is probably decent in stock form and I know this would be an over kill but I do plan on flying it in open class competition and would like the extra launch/winch ability without worry.

I do plan on wrapping the joiner boxes with kevlar thread. Not sure if I am creating a major stress point at the wing joiner box going from carbon spar back to bass wood in the tip panels?

The cost is about $25 vs. $8 for the tape but not really a big concern if it is easier than laminating carbon tape and sanding down the wood for the correct fit.

I have not seen too many post about just replacing the entire spar cap with a pure carbon cap.

Thank you again for the thoughts

.

Craig
Quote:
Originally Posted by John Walter View Post
The Miarage is a great plane. The key to its design is the balance among all is components.

A solid CF spar will weigh too much. Without changing the rest of the spar, you would simlpy tear off the tips before the main spar saw any substantial load. Also, since there is no balsa sheeting, the wing would flutter long before the main spar loads became an issue.

.007 CF on the top spar, or .014 top and .007 bottom would give more than plenty of strength.
The bend load decreases rapidly as you move from the root to the tip, so that should not be a problem. I have attached a good article that I got somewhere, but don't remember where. Apologies to the author for not giving proper credit....

I tend to agree with JW on this. 14 top and 7 bottom should be quite sufficient as long as you don't try to give it a full-pedal launch with a killer zoom at the end.

One other thing....and very important.... be sure the pieces of your spar fit together well.... no gaps or sloppy workmanship allowed. The webs need to fit precisely between the upper & lower caps, and the ribs.
LVsoaring is offline Find More Posts by LVsoaring
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 09, 2013, 10:23 AM
Registered User
Cambridge, MA USA
Joined May 2001
1,737 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by John Walter View Post
The Miarage is a great plane. The key to its design is the balance among all is components.
A solid CF spar will weigh too much. Without changing the rest of the spar, you would simlpy tear off the tips before the main spar saw any substantial load. Also, since there is no balsa sheeting, the wing would flutter long before the main spar loads became an issue.
.007 CF on the top spar, or .014 top and .007 bottom would give more than plenty of strength.
What he said.

An even simpler way is to add "chordwise" 1/8" square basswood doublers to the top sparcap, stepped in length. The Mirage center panel is 48" long. Making the three doublers about 30", 18", 9" in length will give a nice ramp-up in the strength towards the center. I would also add a 1/8" square doubler about 9" long to the top tip sparcap.

This will double the wing's bending strength, and add maybe 8 grams.
markdrela is offline Find More Posts by markdrela
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 09, 2013, 11:38 AM
Registered User
Mark Miller's Avatar
St. Louis, MO
Joined Oct 2002
2,708 Posts
The question is really do you need the carbon? There is a myth that a winch is a really good way to break your wing. As a matter of fact that is what they were designed to do. in fact you can be easier on a wing with a winch as long as you use the off part of the foot switch. I have launched HLG's with all balsa spars without breaking them. It can be done. Plenty of my customers have built their Mirages with no carbon. Maybe a bit of wrapping the joiner boxes and are still flying the models. So I would suggest that you think about what the real benefit will be with adding carbon to a Mirage wing. I'm not saying don't do it but just to think about it and asking questions here like this is a good start.

Mark Miller
Isthmus Models
Mark Miller is offline Find More Posts by Mark Miller
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 09, 2013, 12:13 PM
Registered User
stewswanson's Avatar
United States, PA, Harrisburg
Joined May 2012
55 Posts
spar

Agree with the .014/.007 or.028/.014 for the center. I put 4mm square carbon (has a hole in the middle so it really isn't too heavy)tip caps in mine with kevlar wrap and laminate .080 x .5 carbon into the joiners which are a high failure component.
Stew
stewswanson is offline Find More Posts by stewswanson
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 09, 2013, 02:46 PM
Registered User
So. Cal
Joined Jan 2005
137 Posts
Thank you for all the feedback. It helps.

Some of my take aways-

1. Overkill in strength and will unbalance the load charateristics of the wing.
2. Probably will add 2-3 onces of weight.
3. The plane may be fine with no carbon, so why go crazy in the other direction.

The advice seems to be geared towards a more moderate solution if I want to do something.

Thank you again.

Craig
TOSSPilot is offline Find More Posts by TOSSPilot
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 09, 2013, 05:31 PM
HyperFlight Support
Neil Stainton's Avatar
United Kingdom, England, Stratford-upon-Avon
Joined Feb 2001
3,867 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by TOSSPilot View Post
1. Why not just replace the bass spar cap witth the carbon one vs. laminating the carbon tape?
A spar needs a shear web to work. If you change the spar caps to carbon you will have to also increase the strength of the web in proportion. Probably just increasing the vertical grain balsa web thickness to the full width of the spar cap will be okay.

Neil.
Neil Stainton is offline Find More Posts by Neil Stainton
Reply With Quote
Old Feb 09, 2013, 06:18 PM
Kurt Zimmerman ≡LSF 4461≡
kzimmerm's Avatar
Montrose, NY
Joined May 2003
1,349 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by Neil Stainton View Post
A spar needs a shear web to work. If you change the spar caps to carbon you will have to also increase the strength of the web in proportion. Probably just increasing the vertical grain balsa web thickness to the full width of the spar cap will be okay.

Neil.
That is what I'm doing for a spar mod on my next woodie project. In fact it is going to much like the Maxa spar. It will comprise of 4 pieces of balsa cut on a 45 degree bias laminated together with a .014 carbon core. spar caps will be dimensional carbon wrapping with Kevlar. I figure it should be full-peddle winch safe.
Kurt
kzimmerm is offline Find More Posts by kzimmerm
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Category Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Question Carbon reinforcement for Woody Wing Spar Niko03 Thermal 15 Jan 08, 2013 11:42 AM
Discussion Carbon fiber spars/? methods of fabricating Stan_in_AR The Builders Workshop 1 Dec 19, 2007 02:02 PM
Discussion Moth Spar Cap - Alternative Method jtoro Slope 21 Mar 21, 2006 03:29 PM
Carbon Fiber/Spruce Spar Cap Construction Questions Joe Minton Sailplane Talk 1 Nov 10, 2003 08:53 AM
[B]Carbon Fiber/Spruce Spar Cap Construction Questions [/B] Joe Minton Sailplane Talk 2 Nov 10, 2003 07:50 AM