|Feb 26, 2014, 12:29 AM|
Australia, QLD, Brisbane
Joined Sep 2012
Sunnysky X2204 2300KV Thrust Test - 2S + 3S
Sunnysky X2204 2300KV
A decent mini motor has been a long time coming! Good thing it was worth the wait! The Sunnysky X2204S 2300KV has become an instant hit in the mini multirotor world, and with good reason, it is the perfect balance of performance and price.
I do believe it is being under utilised in the majority of applications using 5 inch props, and I hope these figures will encourage growth in frames designed for 6 inch props, (Particularly the HQ Prop 6x3 on 3S), to fully take advantage of the power we now have at our disposal.
Matching motor and prop is necessary to get every ounce of performance from the system, and it is a highly dynamic equation. I believe the perfect balance with the SS X2204S 2300KV on 3S is the HQ Prop 6x3 for all-round & heavier applications (such as mini FPV), and the FC 6x4.5 prop for lightweight acro frames.
3S Tests and Figures...
2S Tests and Figures...
- HQ 6x3 is producing more thrust, on less amps and travelling faster than the other 3" pitch props. Plus it is still maintaining a constant WOT RPM.
- In the 2S test it can be seen the FC 6x4.5 sits well between the 6x3 and 7x4 props
- The 4.5" pitch gives a comparable thrust plus a higher speed.
- Can't just compare Thrust, Amps and Efficiency, also need to consider Pitch Speed. At times the 4.5 pitch props seem less efficient, but they are travelling much faster.
I am testing with fully charged lipos as it is just the easiest way for me to get a constant voltage between tests. I use the biggest packs I have and four in parallel (most of the time) for consistency. I would prefer to test at the nominal voltages, or actually both. The most useful comparison here is the relative comparison between props given the same conditions.
It also gives an absolute maximum which I think is useful in its own right, even though a single lipo will not sustain that same voltage. I do think though, keeping a motor static on a bench introduces its own testing inaccuracy that is not present in flight. Once the props are free to move, it should allow a single lipo to maintain a better voltage than it could on a bench.
The 50% position is just eyeballed on my TX, but I have tested the repeatable accuracy to between 1500-1512us in the MW GUI. Not exact, but close as I can atm
Using 70% of free RPM point (on the bench), as a gauge of motor / prop combination seems to work well in practice. This runs a motor too hot on the bench but, by mine and other's empirical flight reports, seems to be the best combination in flight.
For the props that load the motor too much on the bench you can see and hear thrust and RPM drop off immediately after full throttle is reached. I only leave these tests at WOT for a very short amount of time so to not burn out the motor.
For an idea on how this is working in practice, here are the results for the FC 6x4.5 on 3S.
2.86 G/W eff
68% of Free RPM
At over 20 amps and 250 Watts from a 20g motor (12.5 W/g = 4x the 3g/W rule of thumb)... This looks like an unattainable combination. But on a lightweight quadcopter, with another 3 motors all lifting twice the AUW each, the motor unloads in flight when freely moving through the air.
Here is that combination producing a peak of 719 grams of thrust...
And here in flight with the 6x4.5's on 3S, 300g AUW acro quad.
No free rides here, all components are working to their limit
HQ Prop 6x3 Flight test.
HQ Prop 6x3's on the warpquad. Slightly less speed from the lower pitch, but heaps of traction and bite, which should suit heavier FPV quads perfectly.
You can hear the motors have more power in reserve with the 6x3 on this lightweight quad, and that reserve should go to good use carrying FPV gear and still remain agile...
Not the best vid... or flying Its a bit hard to see the quad (try HD & fullscreen on Vimeo) but the sound is very revealing of just how quick the quad responds with these props.
2014-04-30 Edit... New HQ Props...
Bench test of the new HQ Props. Sunnysky 2204 2300KV on 3S.
Both the 5x4 and 6x4.5 are absolutely fantastic props. Much more rigid than the competition, better made, smoother running, and more powerful...
The 6x4.5 is a clear favourite of mine, an absolute powerhouse of a prop! It hit a peak of 765 grams of thrust compared to about 500 grams max from the 5" props. See pic below.
I highly recommend the 6x4.5 for the most powerful mini FPV ships. It is rigid, smooth and 50% more powerful than the best 5" props. This is a huge plus for a sport copter when carrying FPV equipment.
They run the 2204 2300's to the limit on 3S and you need to ensure your system is capable. One setup I fully intend to try is the 6x4.5's + Tiger MT2206 2000KV motors + KISS 18A ESCs on 4S
Well done again HQ Prop!!!
HQ Prop 6x4.5 peak output...
|Feb 26, 2014, 05:40 AM|
Australia, QLD, Brisbane
Joined Sep 2012
Thanks guys! Also forgot to mention I tried a 4S test but had sync issues with my BS30A + SimonK 2013-05-15. I looked to changing over to a Ultra ESC but its RPM limits were listed as below what actual RPMs would be, so I canned the test.
Felix had his new KISS ESCs running 2300KV motors on 4S so I'll check what laws of physics he's bending there, and try avail myself of this power as well
Here are quick pics of the props used (in order of appearance).
I'll update the first post with better pics when I have them...
|Feb 26, 2014, 09:24 AM|
Joined Dec 2009
That is awesome Thank you.
You got me looking at the 20amp Afro ESCs. " Thin ones" Plenty amp head room and they only weigh 12-13grams with wires.
|Feb 26, 2014, 09:29 AM|
Thanks much, after burning out one of my sunnyskies on my BO mini hex I was wondering what I'd do with the other 5... now I know. I shall slap together some spare wood with space for 6" props, and have at it!
I always thought the sunnyskies had more in 'em than just 5" on 3S. They're pretty wide and torquey.
|Feb 26, 2014, 09:52 AM|
Holy crap, Soma... That is some pretty insane flying.
Would love to send you a 258 carbon fiber frame for you to put it through this treatment. Just say the words and I'll have it in the mail for you.
|Feb 26, 2014, 09:54 AM|
Are you sure the afros are only 13g? On hobbyking they are listed at 20g...
Do the afros work nicely with this sunnysky x2204 2300kv?
|Feb 26, 2014, 09:58 AM|
Joined Jun 2012
Thank you for all the time, money, and personal effort you are putting into this, and the Warpquad!
Solid testing setup to produce reliably comparable data. Good consistent testing procedure. Extensive selection of props. I appreciate you including 3-bladed props, even though I would never fly with them again after realizing how much better 2-bladed props work in real life. Excellent collection of data (incl. video) and super-clean presentation in JPG table that allows consistent viewing.
Love the clean macro shot of the 2204, too! While the 2204 2300KV now has good circulation and availability, decent product photos have been impossible to come by.
Once again, kudos, Soma! <Deep bow in front of my mini-quad guru.>
|Feb 26, 2014, 11:29 AM|
Wow that flying is fast, are you sure you did not fast forward the video, lol, j/k.
Very nice presentation of pictures, video and charts. SS 2204 users and frame makers will find this report very useful. With this charts, folks will be buying the SS2204 like food/water as if there is a major disater .
I'm interested on the FC 5x4.5 props as they produced the most thrust on 100% throttle, are the BS 12 amps ESC still okay with a 18.22 amps surge?
|Feb 26, 2014, 11:42 AM|
Amazing, you can tell just by ear which props are too pitchy and significant voltage drop happens in the first 5-10 seconds. But wow these things are seriously impressive
I picked up 5 of them for a 250-300 size frame along with a bunch of the 6x3 props, looks like it will be absolutely nuts, I will be using 1800 3S 40C packs, BS12 ESCs and a Naze32 board.
Can't wait to get it built and in the air!!
Great work and flying Soma, mad props (literally)
|Category||Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Off Site||SunnySky X2204 2300kv *New in Stock*||witespy||Aircraft - Electric - Multirotor (FS/W)||61||May 30, 2014 11:45 AM|
|Sold||3S Flyduino Nanoquad - Sunnysky X2204-2300KV motors - Plush 10A BLHeli ESCs||AlienQuads||Aircraft - Electric - Multirotor (FS/W)||0||Jan 13, 2014 09:10 AM|
|Sold||Flyduino Nanoquad 3S - Sunnysky X2204-2300KV Motors||AlienQuads||Aircraft - Electric - Multirotor (FS/W)||3||Jan 09, 2014 04:42 PM|
|Sold||SunnySky X2204 2300kv *new in box*||p0st4L||Aircraft - Electric - Multirotor (FS/W)||22||Dec 28, 2013 07:51 PM|
|Sold||SunnySky X2204 2300kv *new in box*||p0st4L||Aircraft - Electric - Multirotor (FS/W)||24||Dec 12, 2013 08:52 PM|