

United States, NJ, Roseland
Joined Apr 2009
2,242 Posts

Discussion
Amp x Volt = Watts Somethings wrong.
Look at these rimfire 1.20 numbers:
Max. Constant Current: 50A Max. Surge Current: 80A Max. Constant Watts: 1480W Burst Watts: 2360W No Load Current: 2.3A Input Voltage: 18.522.1V (56S LiPo) RPM/V (kV Rating): 450 If I take the max. constant current 50 amps and multiply it by 22.1 (6s) I get 1105 watts?? too low compared to their specs. Or if i take the max burst rate of 80 amps and mult. by 22.1 I get 1768 watts. Still too low for theit max. burst watts. Am i doing something wrong? Now if I take their numbers and want to figure out the motors amp capacity. I'd take watts (max surge) 2360 divided by volts (6S) 22.1 = 106.7??? WAY higher than their 80 amps listed. SOmethings fuzzy......Could be me. Dave 




bartricky is on to something there, I think. Rimfire appears to have used something a touch higher than "nominal voltage" when they calculated their numbers. Reverse the math with their numbers to find out what voltage they calculated from...that will tell you how bogus or not the numbers are.
fresh lipos are 4.2 per cell.....under load that number drops to maybe 3.8 when fresh, 3.4 when half depleated.... They could have use any number of cells at any voltage within that range to generate their numbers.....and any answer within that window would not be technically wrong. Motor specs are always a ballpark sort of a thing...your milage will vary a bit due to the specifics of your setup. 



just went back to post one and ran the numbers......29.5 volts is the answer for the constant and burst numbers. So they used a seven cell fully charged (29.4)to get those numbers?? OR an 8 cell at nominal (3.7) voltage, which is 29.6 volts???? Seems to me, somebodys asleep at the wheel at rimfire....
Have you looked into Scorpian brand motors? they have motor/prop charts that state truthfully what voltage and prop were used.....they have at least 8 different numbers combos graphed for every motor they make. Mountainmodels.com sells them. CommonsenceRC.com also has accurate usefull number charts for their motors....also worth a look for you?? I hate buying things from manufacturers who just print random bogus things and expect us to follow the herd.....call rimfires bluff and buy from someone who publishes true numbers. 


Tucson, AZ
Joined Oct 2008
1,056 Posts

If you multiply 8S voltage by those current numbers, you'll find that the advertised numbers fall out (though the burst wattage is eight watts lower than what my calculator says it should be, assuming a percell voltage of 3.7V) So I'd guess they tested the motor at 8S to make their power numbers look better. Can you use the motor at 8S? I wouldn't recommend it.



United States, NJ, Roseland
Joined Apr 2009
2,242 Posts

Now funny thing is that the eflite power 110 has lower numbers but its rated for 8S??? Im just trying to figure out if this motor can stand more amps??? if you look at the burst watts its 2360 Thats a lot of watts. So if its rated for 2360 burst, the motor must be able to handle 8090 amps right?!?!?!?!?!? Either their AMPS or WATTS are off. Question is which? My guess is the AMPS. I hope : )




Tower Hobbies really needs to get their act together. They are missing the EPower boat.




Nothing wrong with showing max values for max watts continuous and max watts burst at levels beyond those achieved using the suggested cell count and amp draw. Shows the amount of safe operating envelope available out past the normal max cell count and amp draw.
Do you run your car engine at max temp and max rpm on the dial all the time? Nope. I predict that GP set a conservative operating envelope for the Rimfire to keep reliability high and warranty work low. 
Latest blog entry: 2014 events and travel





So they crank up the numbers with a huge battery, and then turn around and tell you not to use that battery....that means that the ratings they are advertising are beyond what you can acheve with the reccomended equipment?? That's a load. I want numbers that are relavent to a real world setup.
I choose usefull data with my wallet!! NUF SAID 


United States, NJ, Roseland
Joined Apr 2009
2,242 Posts

looks like im going to scorpion in the future....so since i have this one rimfire, if I use their watt numbers 1480 max constant 2360 burst, could i use a 8, 9 10S lipo as long as I keep the watts within those parameters?




Sounds locical enough.....but a guess is a guess, and yours is as good as ours..

Thread Tools  
Similar Threads  
Category  Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
Discussion  V3 Data Logger Records Wrong Volt & Amp Data  tsurt  Eagle Tree Systems  12  Jan 22, 2011 01:01 PM 
For Sale  12 volt power supply. 20, 30 ,40 & 45 amp models. Unbeatable prices!  directdeals  Aircraft  Electric  Batteries & Chargers (FS/W)  0  Oct 01, 2010 12:13 PM 
Discussion  Bought RCEBL35x & Thypoon 2215 Somethings not working .  spllouder  Electric Heli Talk  8  Sep 08, 2010 02:49 PM 
Amp, Volt, Thrust, Watts???  CooHead  Parkflyers  26  Apr 02, 2004 11:01 AM  
somethings wrong with my NIMH  RonPlanes  Batteries and Chargers  4  Feb 16, 2004 07:49 AM 