Thread: Download RC-USB Joystick Files
View Single Post
Old Mar 02, 2008, 04:00 PM
JDill is offline
Find More Posts by JDill
Registered User
JDill's Avatar
United States, MI, Traverse City
Joined Nov 2004
76 Posts
Problem solved! It turned out to be the apparently not-so-equivilant transistor I had used.

When building up the NG2 I just moved over the 2N3904 I had used in my M&M build, and had similar results. The old Futaba FG worked but the newer 6EXA didn't. The 2N3904 was listed as being a cross for the BC550C.

So then I went with a BC107 as listed on Alessio's schematic (which I had) and it worked for both builds! I then also tried a 2N2222 and it worked just fine too.

Back to the scope. As I mentioned previously the amplitude of the signals at the base of the transistor were the same. But, at the collector/pin 21 of the pic there is a difference. With the BC107 it is 4.9v with both transmitters on both builds. With the 2N3904 it is 4.2v (FG) and 2.8v (6EXA) on the M&M build. On the NG2 it is 3.8v (FG) and 1.7v (6EXA).

I looked at the data sheets for these transistors but I don't know enough to tell what might cause the difference.

At least it made me get out and play around with the scope again. It's been fun building these up, and I might even use them with a simulator now!

Jeff
JDill is offline Find More Posts by JDill
Reply With Quote