"....but is it P-40ish enough to satisfy P-40 fans? Why are those wonderful windows that allow the pilot to look over his shoulder to see if anyone is on his 6 represented only by silver panels in the MonoKote covering?"
That's the one they could have done better on. Real windows versus "stickers" are what is supposed to differentiate a plane like this from the GWS Beaver.
I think they cheesed that one.