RC Groups

RC Groups
    Fuel Plane Talk
        Build Log Building "VK Navajo" as Float Plane

#1 GLGofLB Oct 31, 2012 07:02 PM

Building "VK Navajo" as Float Plane
 
9 Attachment(s)
I love RC Group build logs almost as much as buying stuff :D on RC Groups. I of course have a few Scale dream builds stored in the closet but those can take a :censored: LONG time. Before I tie up the work bench forever I want to round out my stable of Sunday and everyday fliers. I have the usual amount of half built projects laying around but I do mangage to complete an airplane every now and again. On Memorial day I bought a Carl Goldberg Super Chimpmunk online. Thought I would knock it out in a month;). Well ten weeks later the shop gave birth to an Art Scholl style Super Chimpmunk.
Attachment 5271732

Attachment 5271733
RC Club has a monthly Float Fly at our facility and after 10 years I still dont have a decent float flier. A few months ago I won a VK Navajo kit at a club meeting, and I decided this would make a cool float plane. I like the high wing and the fully symetrical sheeted stab and all balsa sheet design fuse. I figure I can fiberglass the entire plane and floats cover the wing in matching Monokote and be off to the races. So if your so inclined please join me on this build, hopefully this will be done in a couple of months and I will a post video of its maiden flight at our February float fly.
Attachment 5271768

Belive it or not this was four nights work sorting this stuff out. Now i have to get going and start gluing sticks together.

#2 buzzard bait Oct 31, 2012 10:16 PM

I'll watch. Our oldest club member built up a Navaho to the point of priming it with dope/talc and then stopped and he has had it unfinished for probably decades. But seeing how pretty it was in primer made me curious about the plane. They never caught on like the Cherokee, so you don't see much about them.

Jim

#3 tailskid2 Oct 31, 2012 10:41 PM

Ah, that looks exciting....real BALSA and a Kit to boot :) Brings back memories......

#4 buzzard bait Nov 01, 2012 06:51 AM

Engine must be either 62V or 95V...which one?

#5 GLGofLB Nov 01, 2012 12:42 PM

I just recently started flying 4 strokes and I really like their performance once they break in. I am also an OS person on on alcohol engines, I thought the the OS-62 would be a perfect compromise between size and power. I like to have turnkey airplanes so I purchased the new V twin design specifically for this plane, actually less expensive than the Surpass and the only new one of that displacement. This kit is a 60's or 70's vintage and the box calls for a 60 engine however at 64 inch wingspan it could easily fly well on a 46. Back in the day the engines did not put out the power we do now. With the added drag of the floats I think the FS-62V should be sweet.:phttp://www.osengines.com/engines/osmg0898.html

#6 GLGofLB Nov 01, 2012 12:46 PM

On another note. Does anbody know if the "Ventral Fin" in the Great planes Float kit which sticks out the bottom of the fuse is really necessary/:confused:
I think it is intended to take out adverse roll tendencies when attempting to yaw a float airplane.

#7 pd1 Nov 01, 2012 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GLGofLB (Post 23156288)
On another note. Does anbody know if the "Ventral Fin" in the Great planes Float kit which sticks out the bottom of the fuse is really necessary/:confused:
I think it is intended to take out adverse roll tendencies when attempting to yaw a float airplane.

The ventral fin added to the fuselage on a float plane is to compensate for the forward side area added when floats are installed.
There is more side area forward of the CG than behind the CG on a typical set of floats. This can make the plane act like it has too small a tail.

Some planes don't need the added area, while some actually become slightly unstable without the added tail area.

#8 GLGofLB Nov 01, 2012 04:05 PM

Thanks for the input, I have seen quite a few models without it and they flew fine. Is there a way to tell in advance of test flying? Because on this model it will be a minor hassle to add it after it is complete. I am inclined to leave it off

#9 buzzard bait Nov 01, 2012 04:08 PM

I think the 62V will prove to be a great choice. I think the 95V would have been a lot of weight in the nose and the power unnecessary for a plane of this type.

Agree with pd1 about ventral fins with floats. Very common on full scale aircraft for just that reason.

#10 pd1 Nov 01, 2012 06:27 PM

The VK Navajo looks very similar to a full sized Cessna with the Omni vision rear window.

The "newer and improved" Cessna rear window reduced the fuselage side area aft of the wing.
The older ones didn't need the ventral fin.

Seems easy enough to add one while you're building the plane, at least it's easier now than later.

#11 GLGofLB Nov 05, 2012 02:45 PM

5 Attachment(s)
Okay, this work every weekday thing is getting in the way of model building. There is so much sorted wood laying around it is time to get started. Since no instructions I chose to start with builing the tail plane (stabilizer) first. Thought tail plane would make me sound smart :rolleyes:

Pretty straight forward plans taped down with wax paper. I build on 1 inch thick glass, so I weight every thing down with home made lead weights. Lower spar die cut ribs first
Attachment 5283439Attachment 5283440


Okay now my first mistake I spot glued the TE an LE. Well the LE is non- symetrical and I glued it on 90 degrees off and the TE was not centered:censored: I used CA solvent to melt the spot glues and re-glued everything correctly. Then CA ed the top sheeting. CA is okay because I can flip the stab over and add more CA to secure the sheeting internally. Note hinge holes in TE, this model is fairly small so I chose to use Carl Goldberg pin hinges. Nice clean look, easy installation and a buddy of mine gave me about 50 extras he had laying around.
Attachment 5283441Attachment 5283474

Finally I cemmented the bottom sheeting on with thin coat of carpenters glue spread on all the mating surfaces. Then lots of weight and walk away to run weekend errands. Best to keep the peace;) The overhanging TE and LE are not just excess, they capture the wingtip blocks that are yet to be added.

Attachment 5283475

#12 Kyler1 Nov 05, 2012 04:10 PM

Well I put the fin on my four star, not sure if it is needed, but I have had it on there for the first few flights. I think I will take it iff next summer and try it without. The GP Float kit seems to be a good kit, I think you will be happy with it.

#13 GLGofLB Nov 05, 2012 05:06 PM

Thanks to pd1 and kylerdinger. I believe that I will be adding the Ventral Fin before I glass the plane. If needs it I am ahead and if it dosen't I will never know the differrence. This is a dedicated float plane, so I might as well stack the deck in my favor. I had a freind who put floats on a Bridi Aircruiser and when we gave full right or left rudder it would respond by doing a full axial roll:eek:. I believe the ventral fin might have counteracted that

#14 GLGofLB Nov 19, 2012 03:32 PM

The continuing saga
 
17 Attachment(s)
Dont you hate it when builders start a thread and disapear?:mad: Well my work and holiday schedule is a little pressing however I am still shooting for the second Monday in February to maiden this airplane model.

This is where we left off with stab pinned and weighted, waiting for its builder.

Attachment 5314758


Next comes the elevator first the hinging then the shaping, almost forgot to add the ply platform for the control horn. First mortise out the slot with my favorite exacto knife chiesel blade, add ply platform, some filler then assemble. Now through the magic of timelapse photography we have the finished stab and elevator hinged with control horn and shaped stab tip blocks.:D
Attachment 5314759Attachment 5314760Attachment 5314761Attachment 5314762





Okay time to move on. Next is the fin and rudder. Very straight forward glue the fin halves over the plans, then sand the under surface to match the stab airfoil. Next I added a mortise to the side of the rudder to receive an inlay ply platform. I sorted through the supplied hardware pack. This pile of rubble will require some serious upgrading. I used to be a purist and only use what came with a kit. I have since learned better.;)

Attachment 5314763Attachment 5314764Attachment 5314765

Continuing on by mortising out the rudder for a ply inlay, then attachment with 2-56 socket screws to secure the nylon horn. (will trim extra screw off later). Rudder mounted checking throw.

Attachment 5314766Attachment 5314767Attachment 5314768

There is a still an unmanagable pile of wood parts on my bench. So I keep punching out things and laying them out over the plans. Major parts and bulkhead laminate pieces.

Attachment 5314769Attachment 5314770

Keep glueing and something will happen. Laminated nose ring bulkhead and tail bulkhead laminates assembled.

Attachment 5314771Attachment 5314772

Finally the plywood firewall laminated to the balsa bulkhead wieghted down leaving us off where we started, looking at lead weights:)

Attachment 5314773

Well its pretty late Sunday night and my workshop buddy is tired out and ready to go in to the house for a long winters nap!

Attachment 5314774

#15 GLGofLB Nov 27, 2012 04:22 PM

Holiday weekend saga
 
11 Attachment(s)
Time to get cracking on the fuselage, lots of die cut parts and no real instructions, just isometrics.

Attachment 5333697Attachment 5333698Attachment 5333699

Need to do some preparation to some of the hardwood blocks and parts.

Attachment 5333700Attachment 5333701

Well believe it or not my digital camera broke! Have you ever heard of such a thing?:confused: Well I am determrined to follow this thread to the end and that meant buying a new camera on Black Friday.:mad: I really was not intending on going out on that day. To make matters worse the new camera was broken straight out of the box, that meant a second trip to the big box store.:censored:Well now I have added further to the economy.;) Learning the camera on the fly. I apologize for the marginal photography.


Attachment 5333702Attachment 5333703Attachment 5333704

Time to make the this fuselage get some depth.

Attachment 5333705

The aluminum landing gear block attaches with four socket head bolts I do not believe they will be accessible after the bottom sheeting goes to place. So I will be fuel proofing this area with epoxy and then attaching bolts with loctite and a lock washers before things get buttoned up. The aluminum plate will hold the strut for the forward attachment to the floats.

Attachment 5333706

Trial fit of chin block.Bottom view with landing gear plate cemented in. Time to mount aluminum landing gear to bottom this will act as main float attachment point. Also time to place servos, engine, throttle cable and pushrod tubes. Easy to layout now, hard once the top and bottom sheeting is in place.

Attachment 5333707


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:01 PM.