RC Groups

RC Groups
    Scale Kit/Scratch Built
        Build Log Short S23 ''C''class , shadows of Ivan

#1 Bart83 Aug 25, 2012 05:09 PM

Short S23 ''C''class , shadows of Ivan
 
15 Attachment(s)
Here i go . . .

This will become the build log of an Short S.23 '' class '' empire airways flying boat.
The scale will be 1/16.5 , this gives a wingspan of 210cm or 82.6 inch

The Short Empire was a medium range four engined monoplane passenger and mail carrying flying boat, of the 1930s and 1940s, that flew between Britain and the British colonies in Africa, Asia and Australia as well as providing service between Bermuda and New York City. It was manufactured by Short Brothers and was developed in parallel with the Short Sunderland patrol bomber of World War II and the piggy-back Short Mayo Composite .

As an 11year old i got a special issue of MAN from my dad. And thats when i first saw it , the beautifull empire flying boat.
It was Ted Russels 120inch rc model on the cover. Since then i was ever hoocked and decided that i was gonna build myself one , when ? i didn't knew but i was gonna build it.

Attachment 5132445

Years ( and many planes ) later i was stumbling arround a great fenomenon : RC groups , here where i read lukeZ short solent 400 threath and i was ammazed by it and immediately the ted russel 120 inch s23 came back on my mind.
So i whent to the attic and searched my old magazines and lucky me i still had it.
Now it was time for some serious plans and with the help of internet it was a lot easier then in 1994.After a lot of '' google '' time i had collected myself a pretty big database with everything i could find on the empire flying boats.
The seawings website is a real good site. And i can really reccomend the book ''flying empire's'' by Brian Cassidy

http://www.seawings.co.uk/
Attachment 5132446
Attachment 5132447
Attachment 5132448
Attachment 5132449

I got my self a copy of the 1:24 plans drawn by Len Whalley an i got a copy of Ivans short solent 400. The idea is to build an Short S.23 using ivans construction methods.

Attachment 5132450

Then there was an other idea that came , i was wanted to learn how to desing rc model using CAD , and this was not easy so the past few years i went on and of with this project but now im finally getting t know rhino3d it is going the right direction and i thought it was time t post a thread.

I now have drawn a 3d model of the plane using the 3view and ivans construction methods , airfoil etc.

The model i will be building is the G-ADHM ''Caledonia'' the second boat build by shorts at Rochester.

Attachment 5132453

The plane is drawn is not exactly 100% scale but i not only want it to be a good looking model , i also want it to fly good so there were some concessions to be made.
Here are the changes i made:

-Used an Selig 7055 airfoil cause i dont know how the gottingen436 airoil will work
- made the fin and stab larger to give good stability
- simplified hull shape to accomadate ivan's construction method
- Scaled cowling and nacelles to give a scale appearance
- changed float struts lengt to give more scale appearance an better water handling

Here are some pictures of what i've done so far , next is to make formers etc.

Attachment 5132454
Attachment 5132455
Attachment 5132456
Attachment 5132457
Attachment 5132458
Attachment 5132459
Attachment 5132460
Attachment 5132461

If you like i can make a step by step photo report of how this model was costructed in rhino, but i first want to know if annyone will read it cause this is a lot of work..

And now t really get in the 1930's mood here is a collection of film i found on the web , enjoy:

Empire flying boats , Africa 1937.wmv (7 min 2 sec)


Greets ,

Bart

#2 Sopwith Mike Aug 26, 2012 03:04 AM

Subscribed - nice collection of information Bart, I'll get round to mine one day...

Mike

#3 trumps Aug 26, 2012 06:02 AM

Great project, looking forward to it!

Cheers
Craig

#4 LukeZ Aug 26, 2012 01:50 PM

Hi Bart, this is a very ambitious project, but you seem to have done a great deal of research and preparation. I think you are also the very same age I was when I began my Solent! (I am guessing approx 29)

I don't know how many people will have a copy of Rhino 3D, so I can not tell you how useful a tutorial there would be. But I am willing to bet some people would be interested in a copy of your plans when you complete them!

Best of luck to you!


Luke

#5 cracksmeup Aug 26, 2012 03:59 PM

Hey Bart Ivans planes and plans are a big shoe to fit in but you have a great plane choice and a good start ,iam sighned up for the build.Keep it light and good luck . :D joe

#6 eflightray Aug 27, 2012 07:37 AM

If it helps at all, there is this thread in the Waterplanes forum -

Short Empire Class "C"

#7 Bart83 Aug 27, 2012 11:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by eflightray (Post 22561133)
If it helps at all, there is this thread in the Waterplanes forum -

Short Empire Class "C"

Thanks for the link , but i already read trough the the thread , too bad the project isn't finished.

Greets ,

Bart

#8 Bart83 Aug 28, 2012 03:38 AM

A colection of photo's to compare

http://a3.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphot...07166301_n.jpg

Greets ,

Bart

#9 GLM Aug 28, 2012 10:33 AM

5 Attachment(s)
Very impressed with your Rhino work Bart, :)

No mean feat to do what you have done. I've been working on a Boeing 314 off and on for the last year. Time and tide...

I have dreams of grandeur of vacuum forming kits of the 314 and the Empire class boats. I have the 3 views of the Empire waiting in the wings (pun intended) :)

It's just so much work as you know to bring it to flight stage. I almost think it takes more than one person to get there.

My construction method would be a vacuum formed outer hull with a seam forming a top and bottom shell, laser cut former structure and a hot wire cut wing. I'm at the surfaces stage. Some pictures below.

I have the capability to machine the molds for the vacuum forming but the machine envelope is only 30" in x travel - so it means many parts as I want a wing span in the 72" range.

Your Empire cad work is fantastic - I look forward to following this thread and your progress with great interest.

Cheers!

Gary

#10 Bart83 Aug 28, 2012 04:39 PM

@ GLM , Thanks for the compliments , your desing also looks great !!

Pretty advanced construction your planning , hope you post a build thread when you start.

Greets,

Bart

#11 Bart83 Sep 03, 2012 04:47 PM

5 Attachment(s)
Here's a small update :

I worked out the construction for the floats , there will be a main former in 3mm balsa and cross formers in 1.5mm balsa. The struts are 3mm carbon spars surrounded by balsa.
The floats are covered with 1.5mm balsa sheeting and the nose and tail blocks are shaped balsa-blocks.
I made an interlocking construction for easy assembly.


Attachment 5132484

Attachment 5132485

Attachment 5132486

Attachment 5132487

Attachment 5132488


Greets,

Bart

#12 Longhorne Sep 03, 2012 05:21 PM

Very nice CAD work, Bart! I'm looking forward to the transition into reality.;)

Paul

#13 Bart83 Sep 04, 2012 01:01 PM

Moved the pictures to the RCGroups server , now possible to view large.

Greets,

Bart

#14 Bart83 Sep 06, 2012 03:19 AM

2 Attachment(s)
Mini update :

Made a start drawing the stabilizer construction , not quite happy with how it turnes out. Starting a new ne tonight and see if i can make a better one with more of the parts interlocking:

Attachment 5136133

Attachment 5136143


Greets,

Bart

#15 Bart83 Sep 06, 2012 04:58 PM

7 Attachment(s)
Redrawn the stabilizer made the construction interlocking using sub trailing and leading edges.

The only thing missing is the carbon spars to join the halves cause i have not
decided wich size i am going to use.

Here are the pictures:

Attachment 5137126

Attachment 5137127

Attachment 5137128

Attachment 5137129

Attachment 5137130

Attachment 5137131

Attachment 5137133

Greets ,

Bart


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:16 AM.