RC Groups

RC Groups
    Electric Plane Talk
        Discussion Tail Dragger or Tricycle Gear?????

#1 RC Trainer plane Apr 25, 2012 11:32 AM

Tail Dragger or Tricycle Gear?????
 
2 Attachment(s)
I'm scratch building a high wing trainer and was wondering if i should make it tricycle gear of a tail dragger. I prefer tail draggers because i feel they look better but i'm so torn between both of them HELP!:confused: Here's the link to the build http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1638287

#2 jrb Apr 25, 2012 11:39 AM

1 Attachment(s)
One of the main reasons Cubs no longer serve as primary trainers.

Make it so it can go both ways!

Especially if you have a nice runway; if not -- dragger.

#3 600Bob Apr 25, 2012 11:43 AM

Depends on your rudder skills. Some tail draggers have mild ground handling others are wild. Nose overs on grass fields can be a problem depending on wheel size and how tall the grass is. I too like the looks of a TG and all but one of my larger planes are TG.

#4 Ed Couch Apr 25, 2012 12:25 PM

For over 30 years a trike gear was considered the standard configuration for a trainer. Much easier to takeoff and land in most siturations. About 10 years or so ago tail draggers made a comeback for no more apparent reason than its cheaper and less complicated to install in an ARF. It is about the same in full size avaition and until the lightweight aircraft started to appear most air vehicles were of a tricycle configuration. Just easier to drive for a fledgling pilot. I've been flying now for over 50 years and seen the cycles and many reinventions. ed

#5 H&H Apr 25, 2012 12:33 PM

We all have to learn tail wheen technique eventually, so why not now? I say Tail Wheel

#6 rcshirt Apr 25, 2012 12:40 PM

good luck with this can-o-worms

#7 Mr. foambuilder Apr 25, 2012 12:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rcshirt (Post 21433010)
good luck with this can-o-worms

A well built and properly setup TD is no harder to manage than a tri-gear. Go with the good loo0ks and become an excellent pilot. Roy;) Flying since 1959 AMA #8045:D:popcorn:

#8 RC Trainer plane Apr 25, 2012 12:57 PM

thanks everbody slightly swaying towards the tail dragger but i'm open for more discussion :D:D

#9 RC Trainer plane Apr 25, 2012 01:00 PM

2 Attachment(s)
HERE's THE LINK TO MY SCRATCH BUILD TAKE A LOOK AND COMMENThttp://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1638287

#10 dedStik Apr 25, 2012 01:10 PM

Make it a TD, you can always slide the front gear forward to help keep it from nosing over on landings. This would make it look more bushplane or cublike.

#11 RC Trainer plane Apr 25, 2012 01:25 PM

Yeah i'm definate now it's going to be a Tail dragger

#12 dkrhardy Apr 25, 2012 03:43 PM

I do not have one nose gear plane! I'm a TD guy, I guess.
Don

#13 SilverState RC Apr 25, 2012 04:04 PM

Really its going to be up to you. Ive been told with full size aircraft a tail dragger will get airborne faster (less runway). Not to mention the fact that you can turn a larger prop as it will sit higher with the tail on the ground. But landing with a larger prop forces you to have to make a 3 point or near a 3 point landing to save the prop.

Ground handling in my opinion is better with a tail dragger. My reasoning for this compared trike gear is if you have to turn hard on the ground with a trike typically the nose wheel works like a pivot point the plane is more likely to tip. Where with a tail dragger your steering from the rear and the tail will swap ends and with little tip over tendancy.

Taking off is pretty much the same you still have to put in a little right rudder to keep it going straight to counter act the torque of the motor. But this is where a tail dragger excells over a trike. Once the tail is flying on a tail dragger you can almost forget about rudder inputs and concentrate on getting the plane airborne. Where with a trike your riding the rudder stick almost untill it gets airborne. But this will also depend on runway surface and wind conditions.

These statements are my opinions and experience's. Others may disagree. But Ive been told by full size aircraft pilots that REAL pilots fly taildraggers.

#14 norcalwelder Apr 25, 2012 04:59 PM

Given the choice I'd go with a tail dragger every day. So many more fun things to do such as wheel landings and three points. I'm biased though cause I got my Private in a tailwheel.

#15 600Bob Apr 25, 2012 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SilverState RC (Post 21434834)
Really its going to be up to you. Ive been told with full size aircraft a tail dragger will get airborne faster (less runway). Not to mention the fact that you can turn a larger prop as it will sit higher with the tail on the ground. But landing with a larger prop forces you to have to make a 3 point or near a 3 point landing to save the prop.

Ground handling in my opinion is better with a tail dragger. My reasoning for this compared trike gear is if you have to turn hard on the ground with a trike typically the nose wheel works like a pivot point the plane is more likely to tip. Where with a tail dragger your steering from the rear and the tail will swap ends and with little tip over tendancy.

Taking off is pretty much the same you still have to put in a little right rudder to keep it going straight to counter act the torque of the motor. But this is where a tail dragger excells over a trike. Once the tail is flying on a tail dragger you can almost forget about rudder inputs and concentrate on getting the plane airborne. Where with a trike your riding the rudder stick almost untill it gets airborne. But this will also depend on runway surface and wind conditions.

These statements are my opinions and experience's. Others may disagree. But Ive been told by full size aircraft pilots that REAL pilots fly taildraggers.

From the perspective of full scale. Tail draggers tend to be more difficult on the ground because the CG is behind the main gear which causes them to want to swap ends, i.e. ground loop, this is a danger as long as the wheels are on the ground but lessens as you reach flying speed. You don't stop "flying" a TD until it has come to a complete stop. With a trike the CG is ahead of the main gear and tends to keep the plane straight when the wheels are on the ground.

Trikes don't like hard turns in a high speed taxi, they tip over like a kids tricycle. The proper takeoff technique is to lift the nose wheel as soon as possible. In a soft field takeoff you pull the yoke to your chest right from the start then let off pressure as the wheel comes off the ground so you don't whack the tail on the ground.

Both types require you to stay on the rudder because of the left turning tendancy of torque and P-factor.

Real Pilots fly tail draggers because they are more difficult to take off and land plus pilots tend to have big egos and Trikes are used as primary trainers for ease of ground handling.

Yes I have flown full scale and have flown TD but only for a flight review and not to solo them.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:30 AM.