View Full Version : Discussion Combat Plans for the Scratch Builder
Sixter
May 17, 2009, 08:46 AM
Ok Guys, lets share our favorite Combat Plans here with Downloads and Links to Combat Build Threads from Plans. It can be one that you designed or didn't design, just remember to give credit to the Designer. Lets keep this Thread for Scratch Built Combat Models only, no Kits please!
Thanks
Sixter
Sixter
May 17, 2009, 09:02 AM
The Simple Delta designed by Dekan is a Great Delta for Combat Flying! It's very Simple to build, its only five parts! Can be made from EPP, FFF & Depron Foams. Flys great at Fast or Slow speeds! Here is the Build Thread http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=867083 Picture is of Dekan's Simple Delta. Thanks Dekan for sharing your Simple Delta :D
Sixter
dekan
May 17, 2009, 10:48 AM
Hi All... check out the No #1 post as the SD has been improved..added 1 more bit..a KF wing section... :)
It's even stronger now as it has a double thickness LE :D
MumblinBerk
May 18, 2009, 06:13 AM
Laugh if you wish, but here's a pick of "Franken-Stick". I loved to play the role of "Target" for various Strykers, and Wings. She was a tough old bird, lots of CF and epoxy keeping those wings together.
Streamers???? We don't need no stinkin' streamers!
-berk
MumblinBerk
May 18, 2009, 06:17 AM
Aww rats. Sorry, just realized I posted that in the Scratch-builder's thread. My bad.
kingsflyer
May 18, 2009, 08:12 AM
Here is a picture from SEFF 2009. The Green one is Dan's Foamenator design that was the 1st place prize and the Red/White/Blue is the Texas Terminator the won the Combat Event. The TT is my shameless copy of Dan's design. I used FFF, CF leading edge reinforcement, Hobby Lobby 400XT motor, and Spectrum RX.
McD
dlw151947
May 19, 2009, 03:13 PM
Here's some photos of our Delta we fly full contact with.
DLW
kingsflyer
May 20, 2009, 04:03 AM
Here's a link to the "plans" for the Foamenator:
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=830081&page=3
See post #36
I know this thread is for homebuilt designs, but sometimes really good homebuilt designs get to be kits and ARFs. Here's where you can get kits and the ARF for the Foamenator:
http://www.gwsprops.com/electric_combat_plane_as_seen_on.htm
Enjoy,
McD
Sixter
May 21, 2009, 05:26 PM
Hi Guys, Thanks for your contributions to our Thread :D
Dekan: Keep em coming :)
Kingsflyer: Thanks for sharing your Texas Terminator and the Link Info. I agree with you, all great designs began as Scratch Built Models!
MumblinBerk: Old Franken-Stick has the scares to prove that she's a Tough Old Bird :D
dlw151947: Your Delta is truly a Cheap, Disposable, Combat Fighter :D Can you share a little Info on the Motor, ESC, Battery Pack, and Prop?
Anyone who has something to share, please post it :)
Thanks
Sixter
arsenic0
May 21, 2009, 08:26 PM
Is anybody building any Electric combat wings out of Coroplast?
I am curious why more people dont use Coroplast for the designs, as it takes a much stronger beating...
2mm Coro makes a plane similar in weight to a EPP/FFF plane, and its seemingly industructible...
Or is it just because its harder to find?
Wish i had more people to combat with out here in Oregon, all my buddy wants to do is combat his 100mph stryker against my plane...
I think i may take him up on the offer soon, if he hits my Coroplast Mugi even if i die his plane will shatter on impact...
My total cost - 3 dollars
His total cost - 50 dollars
Sixter
May 22, 2009, 09:50 AM
arsenic0 Can you post Info and pictures of your Coroplast Mugi :)
Thanks
Sixter
Lee
May 22, 2009, 12:16 PM
Combat is more than hitting each other it is flying in slow formation and making multiple contacts without destroying the other plane. No one will stay with combat if every time you hit the planes are destroyed.
We have a few Strykers fly in our combat here. They fly well but they don't survive too long.
I have not seen a Coroplast plane that can fly as well as the EPP wings. Please post some video.
Dr. Sandy Frank
May 22, 2009, 01:06 PM
Combat is more than hitting each other it is flying in slow formation and making multiple contacts without destroying the other plane. No one will stay with combat if every time you hit the planes are destroyed.
We have a few Strykers fly in our combat here. They fly well but they don't survive too long.
I have not seen a Coroplast plane that can fly as well as the EPP wings. Please post some video.
is this 1/4 inch EPP???????
arsenic0
May 22, 2009, 01:38 PM
Combat is more than hitting each other it is flying in slow formation and making multiple contacts without destroying the other plane. No one will stay with combat if every time you hit the planes are destroyed.
We have a few Strykers fly in our combat here. They fly well but they don't survive too long.
I have not seen a Coroplast plane that can fly as well as the EPP wings. Please post some video.
Well heres some google videos..theres a few good examples of the particular coro plane I am flying which is the Mugi
http://mugi.co.uk
http://mugi.co.uk/evo_youtube.php
Video 3 shows a pretty good speed crash that i know would have ripped my EPP/FFF planes in half..
The question isnt necessarily can this design be used in combat, because even though this plane has some ridiculous agility, much more so than a stryker, it is more at home going fast as hell like a Stryker..
I am interested in trying to replicate some of these EPP designs with Coroplast and see what happens, if anything is MORE durable than EPP. I've smashed my Mugi into the ground probably 15 times at a good 30-50mph..various inverted screw ups or misjudging where a pole is(oops!)...only thing of real substance damage is either to the servos and my battery is a bit mashed now(hope to fix that next plane!).
I'll see if i can take pictures of my Mugi when i get home..but heres one Justin another guy made that IMHO looks epic..
http://static.rcgroups.com/forums/attachments/1/2/9/2/8/3/t1727431-82-thumb-Fokker%20Mugi.jpg
And just FYI for those that DONT know what Coroplast is, its corrugated plastic..think sign board...or how cardboard is but with plastic..doesnt sound all that durable I know...but with proper building techniques(checkerboarding the flutes across eachother) you get wings that are incredibly strong and cant rip.
I understand the point is to crash and not wreck eachothers planes, i want him to build a coroplast plane to fight because my plane will rip his in half of they hit...so far i've said no but he keeps bugging me too ..so i may just have to shut him up if ya know what i mean :)
dlw151947
May 22, 2009, 07:22 PM
Sixter, on the Delta we a 2408-21 motor,2 cell-1300 battery,20 amp speed control and a gws9-7 prop. Everything as cheap as we can purchase.
DLW :)
Lee
May 22, 2009, 08:09 PM
This are some of our club's favorite planes. The club also like Extremewings.com and Unicorns, in fact one of the Unicorn homepage site videos of combat was made by our club.
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=840149
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1052384
Watch the videos we have 40 planes in the air.
We have done combat twice a week for years. We have our own style that draws a crowd and keeps them coming.
dlw151947
May 23, 2009, 07:21 AM
Here's some photos of our Delta we fly full contact with.
DLW
RC/flydad request on the Delta
Motor-2408-21
gws 9-7 orange prop
20 amp.speed control
9 gram sevos
2-cell-1300 battery
spektrum reciever
We fly 5 minute rounds
hot melt low temp.glue everything
the prop slot will have to be made wider for the 9-7 prop and just move the fins out a little
rcflydad
May 25, 2009, 11:28 PM
arsenic0,
Is the Mugi a good combat plane? I have read the Mugi web site and wondered about it in the past. If you don't mind, I have a few questions for you. Where do you buy 2 mm Chloroplast? What size sheets and colors can you get? What electronics, battery, prop, flight time, etc do you get with your Mugi, and where do you buy them at a good price?
arsenic0
May 26, 2009, 02:00 AM
I can see the mugi being a good combat plane because its so indestructible.
Heres my plane, you cant see it but its actually been crashed atleast 10 times not counting bad launches other than the tip of the nose crumpling ever so slightly and some dirt wedged in the nose section you couldn't tell :)
I just need to find a better way to keep my battery from smooshing against the front in hard hits and the only things that can break then are the cheap servos...
http://www.fuzzelogicsoftware.com/images/mugi3.jpg
Not to hijack the thread from its original purpose but ill answer rcflydad..
As earlier i think it would be an awesome combat plane...you can build them out of FFF if you cant get coroplast, my first 2 were out of it and they worked great. I just moved to Coro because I lost both my foam ones in rather epic crashes into a fence and another into a big field light. Both of which resulted in either a lost battery or motor because the airframe itself didnt take much of the force, it just ripped in half spilling all of its guts out from 30+ feet up...
I get my Coroplast locally, they only have white in 2mm but i dont really care because i can tape it up as i did my plane with cooler designs anyways.
Too find 2mm your best bet is to go to google maps and type in 'Sign Shop City, State' like i would do 'Sign Shop Hillsboro, OR'..then start at the top and email or call them all and ask if they use 2mm. I did this to the top 5 and within a few hours a few had said no but 2 or 3 all gave me the name of the local plastic distributor where they get their signboard...called them up and got some.
For me the company is MultiCraft Plastics in Tigard..it was damn cheap ..like 16 bucks for a 8x10' sheet, and they actually screwed up and gave me two sheets! :)
One 8x10 sheet can probably make around 6-8 Standard Mugi Airframes.
I use HXT900 Servos , a Turnigy 2200kV motor, 1800mAH 3S1p Battery, and a 30A ESC, all from Hobby City, total cost probably 50 bucks. I prefer a 6x4 prop, although i have a 7x5 on right now and it works fine. I havent ever timed my flights really, but if i went full throttle the entire time i'd guess 7-10 minutes? But i rarely do that so its usually 12-15ish i'd guess. I started out building the planes with the TowerPro 2408-21T's off Hobbycity, i think they are like 1600-1800kV with 6x4 props and work very well.
The sad(or cool) part is that my AR6200 Spektrum receiver i have in it costs more than everything else in the plane combined(carbon rods, glue, frame, parts)
Also within 5 minutes of this picture being taken i challenged my buddy behind my plane to see who could fly the lowest. I won, he rolled his stryker into the ground and shattered it from like 5 feet...nothin a bit of gorilla glue cant fix tho! He didnt know it but i can actually cut all power and bounce this plane off the ground on its belly and then gun it and take off again..lol..he didnt have a chance.
rcflydad
Jun 05, 2009, 03:37 PM
Hi arsenic0,
I am gathering parts for my first Mugi. I have a few more questions if you don't mind.
What kind of contact cement did you use? I wonder if I could use my really sticky 3M seam seal tape (from Intotothewind.com) on the inside and packaging tape or staple the panels together as needed on the outside to eliminate the need for glue.
I still need to decide on a power system and a mount for the motor.
I have some carbon tubing that is about .290 dia which is slighter bigger than the .240 carbon tube that is recommended.
I found Dubro 1/2A control horns and clevises for the elevons, and 2 mm (.087 in) carbon rod for the control rods. I also found Dubro EZ connectors in a larger size that fit the 2 mm rod.
I have some 2 mm orange sheets, but when they are gone I will need to find a new source for Coroplast in the Seattle area. The manufacturer of Coroplast http://www.coroplast.com/product.htm, phone 800 666 2241 is sending me some 8x10 inch samples.
Found this article on how to decorate a Mugi with colored packaging tape
http://www.instructables.com/id/Styling-a-Mugi-Coroplast-RC-Plane/
Sailor Jerry
Jun 17, 2009, 08:47 AM
Here's some photos of our Delta we fly full contact with.
DLW
Nice plane! What's the all up weight? Also, do you ever use these for streamer combat? I'm not sure I can convince my flying buddies to fly full contact. :)
One more question; when you're using streamers how and where do you attach them? (In case you can't tell, I'm new to combat).
dlw151947
Jun 18, 2009, 09:44 PM
We don't do to much full contact combat anymore since we have been flying the F&F planes. We cut all of our events down to just one event now. It's easier to maintain 1 class of planes rather than several. Even with the F&f planes we still have several midairs.
Buzzy
CCD
Jul 09, 2009, 12:37 PM
Here's some photos of our Delta we fly full contact with.
DLW
Somewhere on these forums I found a link to another website forum that had a PDF with this plane.
However that forum required a signup in order to download the file, and I hate signing up to another forum (always worried about getting spammed).
Any chance that you have that file?
Also one other comment was about using coroplast instead of foam. Here in this part or Canada we don't have a ready supply of the foam your using in the US. So we have been using Coroplast to build some combat machines.
I am looking for something that would be usable indoors in a basketball sized area. Last year we were flying Nutballs that were around 24 inches in diameter with 3 cell packs.
The problem was that with such a large plane was that it was all harrier flying. I'd like something small that could actually be flown in indoors like an actual outdoor combat with turns in all directions and vertical as well as horizontal turns.
davereap
Jul 15, 2009, 05:09 AM
here is my latest.. suitable for combat, fast, manuverable etc quick build sub 1 hr..and so simple. They also are very tough, flying the 32" on a fast pass I hit a square metal goal post, which stopped it dead, the damage was just some LE creasing, not enough to stop flying.
32" span 6mm foam..flys well with a cheapo 2208-21 or power up for maniacs
.
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1077013
go to 24" for a BW motor setup with 3mm foam
32" video
.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zl4UO_aRxwI
.
24" video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e2YpJ3XeA8o
rcflydad
Jul 22, 2009, 04:18 PM
I saw a mention of an F&F plane. What is that and is there a link?
speed2004
Jul 26, 2009, 08:29 PM
See post by Dr. Sandy Frank about F&F combat
dlw151947
Jul 26, 2009, 09:57 PM
I saw a mention of an F&F plane. What is that and is there a link?
Originally Posted by nickeast
Your combat model is the "Blue Funder" It has been around for sometime. The first link below shows the very start and the second link, post #137 has a much more detailed drawing of the plane. You can find out more than you will ever need to know about this great model in these links. There is 41 pages of stuff about mods and various power setups.
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=363570
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/show...=363570&page=10 check post #137
Our group and a couple other groups have been cloning this plane for the last couple of years. By making mods here and there to suit the combat flying we do. It has been working out for us real well in our combat shorties with the equipment we have left over from the WWII planes..And so much more durable and faster build than the WWII planes we have built in the past.
Buzzy
Lommax
Jul 31, 2009, 01:45 AM
Originally Posted by nickeast
Your combat model is the "Blue Funder" It has been around for sometime. The first link below shows the very start and the second link, post #137 has a much more detailed drawing of the plane. You can find out more than you will ever need to know about this great model in these links. There is 41 pages of stuff about mods and various power setups.
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=363570
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/show...=363570&page=10 check post #137
Our group and a couple other groups have been cloning this plane for the last couple of years. By making mods here and there to suit the combat flying we do. It has been working out for us real well in our combat shorties with the equipment we have left over from the WWII planes..And so much more durable and faster build than the WWII planes we have built in the past.
Buzzy
However, the F&F variant looks cooler than the stock "Blue Funder". :p
yzguy
Oct 11, 2009, 10:07 PM
I was going to try to make a Mugi, but I could not find 2mm coroplast, so I ended up getting a For Rent sign, and some 3/16” wood rods from home depot, then cut out roughly from these measurements (earlier post):
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?p=12275893#post12275893
I moved the motor forward just a little, and am using a much smaller prop. I am also obviously using 4mm coroplast, and he used blucore. It will likely fly better when made out of foam, but will likely not be as durable. I may try it both ways.
I am using 1800 to 2200 mah batteries with it, the 2200’s do a little better.
2 of these 9 gr servos:
http://www.hobbycity.com/hobbycity/store/uh_viewItem.asp?idproduct=662
72 mhz receiver
http://www.hobbycity.com/hobbycity/store/uh_viewItem.asp?idproduct=5781
I have one of these motors, I’m not sure which one….
http://www.rctimer.com/index.php?app=goods&spec_id=223
http://www.rctimer.com/index.php?app=goods&spec_id=162
The motor gets a little warm when I push it fast (6X4 prop), but I don’t think it is to much.
vBulletin® Copyright ©2000-2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.