![]() |
| Crack Roll | Flying Giants | RC Power | The E Zone | Lift Zone | Our Sponsors | ||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||
|
Welcome to RCGroups, the most active R/C community on the Internet. Registering with our site is easy and completely free. Registration provides you with the ability to join in on the public discussions, communicate with other members via private messages, respond to polls, upload your photos and videos, post to your own blog, buy and sell RC gear in the classifieds area, and much more. If you have any problems with the registration process, please contact us for additional help. If you've previously registered, please login using the login form below. |
|
||||||||
|
Cox Models Dust Devil ARF Glider Review
Introduction
I had heard about the Cox Dust Devil from a good friend and president of NEAC, Ric Vaughn. At the AMA Nationals, this model had been entered in the electric sailplane contests, and performed quite well. He described the model as a 2m ARF with a poly wing and RES (rudder/elevator/spoiler only) controls - ideal for high altitude thermal hunting yet with spoiler control for spot landings. I was intrigued, as I had not heard of this model prior to this event, and had been planning to modify one of my existing 2m models to include spoilers or flaps.
Kit Contents
The model is packaged in a sturdy cardboard box, each part packed individually in sealed plastic bags. The wing panels are separated by a thin sheet of protective foam. The parts count is extremely low, as can be seen in the picture below. There is a detailed, well-illustrated instruction manual, which covers additional equipment, the assembly sequence, and control setup and balance before the first flights.
The wing panels and tail are pre-covered in Sig AeroKote, and I know from previous experience that this color scheme (using transparent red covering on the wing) is quite visible at altitude in most weather conditions. The fiberglass fuselage is strong, yet light for this size model, and finished in white; the wing and tail surfaces are built up from balsa and ply. I weighed the major components and included hardware before assembly:
Total weight was 590g (20.8 oz) before assembly.
Additional components required are:
No other accesories are required - all pushrods and linkages, control horns, and hardware are provided. A brief note on radio selection should be included. You must be able to operate the spoilers in a proportional fashion,this is usually assigned to the traditional "throttle" channel. It is recommended that the motor be operated by a switch, you will only need one power setting - full on! Consult your transmitter's documentation to ensure you will be able to accomplish this. Many transmitters allow you to assign channel 5 to a landing gear function. This would be a good choice if you have no other way to program the throttle onto a switch - but you will need to purchase a 5-channel receiver or better to accomodate this.
AssemblyWing
The instructions provide detailed information on how to configure the servo arms in order to accommodate the included hardware. With this task performed, installation of the spoiler servo was quick and simple - I deviated slightly from their recommendation to attach this servo with double-sided tape, choosing instead to wrap this servo with tape, securing small blocks to each side of the servo, then using epoxy to hold everything in place. An exit hole for the servo lead was also provided.
The spoiler was then attached to the wing at the leading edge with the provided tape. I found that in the closed position, the outer trailing edges of the spoiler were raised slightly above the surface of the wing. This was remedied by careful removal of a small amount of exposed rib material in the servo opening. The spoiler is somewhat oversized, and should suffice to get the model down from altitude quickly, as well as nailing a spot landing!
The next step was to glue the wing tip panels in place, if so desired. I chose to simply tape them in place at the field, to ease transportation as well as test the durability of the model assembled in this fashion. As luck would have it, I accomplished my goal, and the model survived with no damage!
Fuselage
Assembly of the tail section was quick and simple. The provided, pre-bent control horns were installed into the ruddervator surfaces, which had holes drilled and slots cut in the leading edge.
The ruddervators had to be taped to the tail surfaces, which themselves simply slid onto the preinstalled mounting pins. Again, these may be permanently glued in place, or taped to allow easy transport. I chose the latter, and placed them aside while I continued working on the fuselage.
Motor mount and motor
Installation of the motor mount was once again well documented, and is worthy of further explanation as it utilized a method I had not previously seen. There was a small jig provided, which allowed the mount to be accurately recessed behind the front edge of the fuselage. After ensuring the mount was able to fit into the correct location (sanding the edges at a slight taper), I simply applied a just couple of drops of thick CA (to provide working time), then pressed the jig up against the nose of the fuselage, pressing the mount into place from behind. Once the CA has cured, the jig may be removed, and the mount will remain in place, ready to be permanently secured with epoxy. They recommend adding some chopped fiberglass to the epoxy for additional strength, which I did, and then ran a bead of the mix to both the front and rear edges of the mount.
Note that an additional mount was provided to allow different sized spinners to be used. As provided, the nose matched a 40mm (1.5") spinner, but if a larger (40 or 42mm) spinner was desired, the nose could be sanded back (taking care to ensure the correct thrust angles are maintained), and the large mount installed.
The motor was installed with the appropriate mounting hardware. To simplify routing of the wiring between the ESC and motor, I would strongly recommend planning the motor mount installation such that the wires from the motor follow a natural path down the bottom of the fuselage through the pre-cut opening underneath the battery tray. I did not consider this, and it took a fair amount of effort working in a confined space to get my wiring routed to my satisfaction. I installed a Phoenix 60 ESC in the space beneath the battery tray.
Radio Installation
As detailed information on how to configure the servo arms had been provided before starting assembly, installation of the servos for tail control was quick and simple. With the servos centered, the arms were installed, and the provided clamp-style EZ connectors mounted to the arms. The servos were screwed into the ply mounting plate using the hardware provided with the servos. The ball sockets were screwed onto the provided pushrods, which then slid down the preinstalled pushrod guide tubes and through the EZ connectors. With the tail surfaces taped in place and the control horn ball links connected, the EZ connectors were tightened and the installation of the servos was complete!
The receiver was mounted to the floor of the fuselage behind the servos, providing adequate room to allow the spoiler servo to be plugged in before flight without using a servo extension lead.
Completion
Assembly of this model, not including time for the epoxy to cure, was two hours. I literally finished it in a single morning, including time spent waiting for the epoxy joints (I just worked on other sections while I waited). A quick calculation showed that a 14x8 prop would give adequate performance on 7 cells, and as luck would have it, the model balanced on the recommended 3" mark with a 7-cell CP1700 pack installed at the front edge of the battery tray. A quick test produced 50A current draw (330W) at 5300RPM - more than enough to haul the (46oz finished weight) model around the sky - I would tune the power system once the model had a few flights on it. A couple of strips of Velcro were sufficient to retain the battery. I normally use a strap of some kind, but the design of the tray prevented this, so I simply cut a small block of foam to help hold the battery against the Velcro - in case of "unexpected incidents". With the CG set, and the balance checked (there was no need to add any weight thanks to the tip panels having identical weights!), I set up some reasonable control throws on the surfaces and packed the model up ready for it's first trip to the field. I was excited at the prospect of being able to pack the model back into it's box for transport, but with a spinner installed, the fuselage doesn't fit! A small hole in one corner will solve that, however! I used a good quality white insulation tape to hold the tail surfaces and wing panels in place.
Flying
Although I often test fly models at the local church or school playgrounds, for a model of this size, I prefer to test fly at an official RC field. As it happened, a local club was holding a fly in and cook out for the Labor Day weekend, so the first flights took place just a couple of days after completion of the model.
Basics
A range check and a test glide are essential on any new model, and both were performed without incident. In fact, the test glide was very satisfactory - the model literally flew straight and level, and I did not touch the sticks at all. Then my trusty launcher gave the model another good heave as I applied power, and the Dust Devil climbed for the first time. Power was more than adequate, and I found that the chosen power system provided almost vertical climb capability, not needed for the kind of flying for which this model is intended, but sufficient for me not to worry about changing props for these first flights.
Taking Off and Landing
The model glides well from even a light throw, so launching is non-eventful, and power can be applied before or after release without incident. The spoilers were very effective, and although during the initial flights I spent some time fiddling with the amount of elevator compensation required, I was still able to utilize them to get the model down with some degree of precision. At first, I reduced the throw on the spoiler - even at 45 degrees, the model dropped out of the sky like a brick! With a few more test flights to tune the settings, however, I bumped it back up to 90 degrees, but with sufficient elevator compensation mixed in to maintain a reasonable rate of descent. On it's second trip to the field, we had some wonderful flying conditions - winds were gusty at first, but as the day warmed up and the winds died down, there was some strong thermal activity. I was able to thermal up to about 1400', at this altitude, the dark red covering makes it relatively easy to spot at altitude, yet it lights up nicely when you pass near to the sun. The model can be trimmed to fly at different speeds depending on conditions, which makes it useful in different conditions. In gusty conditions, a couple of clicks of 'down' will bump the speed up, but in calmer skies, a few clicks of 'up' will turn it into a gentle floater. The tail area seems a little small in windy conditions, as the model does dance around quite a bit, but in calm air it's "just right". The control throws recommended work well as a starting point, they are quite high for the "average" pilot, so you might want to start with a 60% low rate setting. My final throws (measured at the root of the surfaces) were:
I did have high rates available which provided "significantly more" throw if needed, but after a lot of flying, never had to use them. In all conditions, during climb, thermal flying, or landing, the rates specified above are sufficient. My best flight so far was just over 20 minutes on a 30 second motor run, and this was the second flight on that charge - the first was a 12 minute flight on a 26 second motor run, after landing, I just picked up the model and re-launched. With the spoiler trim tuned, the model is easy to land with precision, which of course helps in competition, but also valuable to the sport modeler, to ensure he lands in a controlled fashion without risk of over-flying the field. The one addition I've yet to try is some kind of landing skeg. The slick glass fuselage allows the model to slide significantly on landing, and this often also involves rotation of the airframe as one wingtip touches the ground. In most cases, this is not an issue, but a short skeg, to bring the model to a quick stop, would prevent this.
Is This For a Beginner?
One of my first landings resulted in the model performing a ground loop and almost a complete cartwheel in one elegant maneuver! Later, a friend was flying to allow me to take some in-flight pictures, and the gusty conditions resulted in another hard landing. These were unplanned, but did allow me to verify this models ability to survive rough handling, and the strength of the wing and tail assembly when secured only with tape. I am very happy to report that there was no sign of damage, although the pilots should check all controls and linkages before flying, as the ball-link connections can disconnect if the tail control surfaces receive an impact. The Dust Devil is probably durable enough for a beginner - with the caveat that they enlist the help of an experienced modeler to ensure it is trimmed out and set up correctly for flight, and learn to land the model in a controlled manner. The instructions do caution against teaching yourself to fly, but with a little assistance from an experienced pilot, a durable sailplane can make an ideal trainer, and this one definitely fits the bill!
Flight Video and Photo Gallery
Conclusion
The Cox Dust Devil is positioned as an electric sailplane designed to meet the needs of a wide range of electric flyers. The instructions are first-rate, and provide a great deal of detail on assembly and how radio and power system components should be installed. It's flight performance, ease of assembly, durability and price ($130 at time of writing) make it very attractive to both the beginner and more experienced pilot. As electric sailplane competition attracts more traditional "sport" pilots, this model is well positioned to allow those pilots a first taste of this type of flying. That said, the model is also capable of performing well enough to allow the experienced pilot to "take home some hardware"! With a low end brushed power system, this model would fly well, but with a powerful brushless motor, the Dust Devil will quickly reach altitude sufficient for extended thermal flights. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
Thread Tools |
|
|
#2 |
|
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Columbia River Gorge Oregon USA
Posts: 58
|
Are you using the vtail as ailrons or just vtail mixing?
|
|
|
|
|
#3 |
|
SEFF Chef..
Join Date: Jun 1999
Location: Marietta, GA
Posts: 37,771
|
VTail mixing provides rudder/elevator control - there are no ailerons on this model. If you mean do I have it on the right stick, yes, primary turn is always on the right stick (mode 2) so on a R/E model, rudder is on the right stick.
..a |
|
|
|
|
#4 |
|
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Columbia River Gorge Oregon USA
Posts: 58
|
I was thinking you had it mixed in on the computer radio. you may want to corret the article because it reads. " Elevator each direction 5mm (3/16") from center
Aileron each direction 10mm (3/8") from center Spoiler - 90 degrees with elevator compensation 4mm (5/32") "up" at 90 degrees" I have read in somethreads that you can mix ailerons into the tail I just thought you did that. ![]() |
|
|
|
|
#6 |
|
Registered User
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: OKC's Thriving Metropolis
Posts: 833
|
Andy, excellent article! I'll have to step up to the plate on my next review to keep up with you.
One thing I noticed about the plane is the large V-tail. I've been convinced for a long time that most V-tail surfaces are too small. The Super V's tails were large like the tail of the DD and I'm sure that contributes to a great flying V-tail model. gv |
|
|
|
|
#9 |
|
SEFF Chef..
Join Date: Jun 1999
Location: Marietta, GA
Posts: 37,771
|
Not very well.. this is an '05' class model, it is much heavier than the "lightweight" 2m models designed for geared Speed 400 setups. I doubt you could get it to balance with a geared 400 up front (I tried with a speed-400 sized brushless and could not get the model to balance)..
..a |
|
|
|
|
#11 |
|
Registered User
Join Date: May 2004
Location: London Heathrow, Great Britain (UK)
Posts: 1,360
|
The Dustdevil looks like a clone of the Swift V
http://www.hobby-lobby.com/swiftvee.htm Not a good model to fly in windy conditions. |
|
|
|
|
#12 |
|
SEFF Chef..
Join Date: Jun 1999
Location: Marietta, GA
Posts: 37,771
|
The Dust Devil handles wind just fine.. it's a little twitchy, as stated, possibly because the tail could be larger, or the fuselage longer, but it flies great and penetrates nicely. I just trim it a little more for speed in wind, and back for floating in calmer conditions..
..a |
|
|
|
|
#14 |
|
SEFF Chef..
Join Date: Jun 1999
Location: Marietta, GA
Posts: 37,771
|
Don't know that motor or battery, I'm afraid, and they're not in any of the calc programs, so I can't help there.. From the specs on the HL site, it looks promising, but without actual numbers, you'd be taking a chance. I wish more manufacturers and/or distributors would take the time to publish REAL test data for their motors, so prospective customers could purchase a particular combination knowing it would work OK for them. Many experienced modelers can afford to buy a new motor and find a prop/battery combination that works for them. Less experienced modelers depend on accurate specs, or experience of others.
I'd suggest you go with a proven power system for a model of this size and weight (be careful - there are "speed-400" sized 2m gliders that use far smaller power systems..) - feel free to ask here if in doubt! ..a |
|
|
|
|
#15 |
|
Registered User
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Box Elder, SD
Posts: 1,426
|
Thats why I asked, I'm in the boat of I can't really afford a new brushless and ESC they cost so stinkin much. Kinda hurts when you are on fixed income. For this plane I'd want pretty much all new stuff. My MP Jet 28/20-7 and ESC are brand new. Oh well, I'll watch and keep reading. Thanks!!
CrashinJ |
|
|
|
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Similar Threads
|
|||||
| Category | Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Article | Cox Models Christen Eagle ARF Review | Thomas B | Foamies (Kits) | 61 | Jan 04, 2009 10:17 AM |
| Article | Dymond Model Sports Double Blitz -- the Blitz 2 -- Powered ARF Glider Review | Don Sims | Ezonemag Archive | 14 | Dec 23, 2006 10:40 PM |
| Article | Cox Models new EP-380 Electric Trainer ARF Review | Andy W | Ezonemag Archive | 9 | Apr 24, 2006 08:53 PM |
| Cox Models Dust Devil reviewed on LiftZone | Andy W | Electric Sailplanes | 0 | Sep 17, 2005 08:32 AM | |
| Cox Wings Dust Devil | wattsup_kz | Electric Sailplanes | 2 | Jul 29, 2005 11:16 AM | |